5 Reviews Found

Review #1, by Levana  How Hogwarts Scarred Me For Life (by Enid McElderry)

25th February 2018:
Hey, Bex! I’m here with your review! 😊

Okay, so I’m gonna preface this by telling you that I’m not a snamione shipper. I don’t have anything against it, you know, just as long as they’re both adults. So, yeah. I have word doc up side by side with your fic as I read this, so we’ll see how you make me feel about them as I read.

To start off: so far, I find Enid to be hilariously relatable. Just the inner thoughts that she’s having in the first part of the fic were making me laugh (so I don’t really think that humor should be a concern for you because you handle it well). When she’s wandering around the dungeons looking for Toby and she was like, “Some of my worst fears were built with words like Enid! How could your cat lose us all those points! Couldn’t he have waited until the holidays to die?! At which point I would no doubt be rid of all my friends because of a cat who was insistent on his expiry date.” That’s just… so relatable to me. I’d probably think that exact same thing.

And the Snamione bit. Hmm, so I can definitely see why people would ship them – based off the way you have them interacting. Both Snape and Hermione are in character and I actually found this whole scene really amusing. I mean, Snape insisting that he doesn’t need to be walked back to his quarters is just the most Snape thing ever. And then Hermione being like, “My name’s Hermione.” Spot on. They do seem to complement their personalities well.

Then there’s Enid’s reaction, which was just completely spot on for an eleven-year-old. “STOP IT STOP IT NOW, IT’S DISGUSTING, IT’S WRONG YOU’RE MY TEACHERS!!!” This was so funny to me and just very accurate for Enid to be thinking while also being rooted to the spot in shock.’

“I had no intention of marching up to her table and saying, “Trouble in paradise, Professor?” but no one could look that glum over a croissant!” This is very true, croissants are delicious. Also, Enid seeing food in the Mirror is me. That’s me, I’d see food.

Aww, this next part with them by the Mirror of Erised made me sad (then happy)! “I see you…happy. No more tears.” Naww, who knew Snape could be so sa-weeet. This actually really reminded me of Remus/Tonks. Not sure if that parallel was intentional or not, but I really liked it. You know, like the older man thinking he’s not enough for her kind of thing. I thought it was sweet.

“From then on, they didn’t hide what was going on anymore. They were subtle, but god they could be so stupid. And they managed to share their stupidity with me, again.” DID SHE ACTUALLY CATCH THEM CANOODLING?

This whole last section was just hilarious. I mean, them overhearing Hermione and Snape’s conversation. Also, Alex being completely oblivious to it being Hermione was a perfect touch. And then Snape and Hermione thanking Enid for not telling anyone. And them knowing since the library incident that she knew is just so funny.

Okay, so I really enjoyed this. It was funny. Like I said before I don’t think you need to be concerned over writing humor because I thought you did it very well. Like you said there were some grammar mistakes – and I would suggest breaking up some of your paragraphs a bit more.

I think you probably got this by now, but I really like Enid. I thought she was really funny and relatable. I definitely think you should transfer this over to ff.net, if you want I can fully Beta it for you before you repost it – I don’t mind 😊

Also, I don’t ship Snamione (mostly because I really love Ronmione, it’s who I am haha) but I did enjoy reading what you have for them. I actually really think the two characters have good chemistry together. I definitely wouldn’t be opposed to reading more.


 Report Review

Review #2, by marauderfan  How Hogwarts Scarred Me For Life (by Enid McElderry)

25th January 2017:
I'm here with very (very, very) belated holiday gifts. The wishlists are closed now so this is unofficial, just wanted to make sure you got some gifts! By the way, look at your Q&A for another gift as well ;)

So, browsing your page here I saw this one, and if I recall correctly wasn't this the Story of the Month not too long ago? Congrats! So now I'm here to love and review it!

Okay, so clearly the best thing about this story is Enid and her absolutely brilliant narration. She has some great one liners in there - get ready for me to copy and paste some of your own work back to you:

I’d have probably recognised him if she’d used his title, or just called him the dungeon bat. Everyone else did.

no one could look that glum over a croissant!

No actually Enid we wanted to thank you for doing every bit of homework on time – we actually have no idea what you’re on about

There were loads more but those ones really stood out to me and made me laugh. Enid's internal monologue was great. Poor Enid, forced to know all about this secret affair and have it follow her throughout all of her Hogwarts years. Especially when you're eleven and the idea of your teachers having a love life is just... wrong. Hahaha! That and the fact that one of the people is the dungeon bat, whom Enid is terrified of.

I love how Hermione is really kind to Enid though and helps her find her cat, and it's clear throughout the story that Hermione's kindness has changed Snape, as well. I can't imagine Snape being that lenient a generation earlier, if Ron had been found in the corridor looking for Scabbers. He'd have a week's worth of detentions.

Also, poor Hermione. To bring Snape to the mirror of Erised and hear him say that after so long he's still hung up over Lily. At least he did seem to move forward at that point.

The way you wove together the romance and the humour was wonderful - it never got sappy because of the rather uninterested narrator, but it still showed the progression of their relationship and contained sweet moments.

This was really well paced and I have to say again that I just loved Enid's voice in this story. I can see why this won featured story! Well cone!

 Report Review

Review #3, by Emcnary  How Hogwarts Scarred Me For Life (by Enid McElderry)

30th December 2016:
Gah! I loved that little story so much:)

Author's Response: thank you!


 Report Review

Review #4, by ABlack  How Hogwarts Scarred Me For Life (by Enid McElderry)

17th December 2016:
Where do I even start? Perhaps I should warn you that I absolutely love Snape/Hermione - they’re one of my all-time favorite pairings. So I went into reading this wondering what the girl in the banner, with her eyes as wide as saucers, possibly had to do with Snape/Hermione.

Merlin’s ever-loving balls (of fire), I was totally unprepared! First off, her name: Enid. Not exactly a common one, and I should know - it’s actually my middle name. Then her cat and her fear of losing points because the darn cat might die. Quirky? Yes, in an adorable way. But her reaction to them swapping spit? OMG, you had me giggling out loud. Enid’s internal screaming dialogue was just too perfect! I swear this story should come with a ‘beware of snorting your coffee’ advisory because that’s what nearly happened to me. That she had to continually put up with stumbling into their moments throughout her years at Hogwarts was crazy and hilarious.

There were so many great lines, too, like ‘no one could look that glum over a croissant’ and ‘Enid McElderry please, your Slytherin is showing.’ Enid is a delightfully funny narrator, particularly because she wasn’t trying to be funny.

Overall, this story highlights that you certainly have a comedic streak. Great job!


 Report Review

Review #5, by Rumpelstiltskin  How Hogwarts Scarred Me For Life (by Enid McElderry)

30th August 2016:
Hey! I'm here with your Slytherin Hot Seat Review (and running late, at that).

One of the initial elements that struck me was the fact that Enid, unlike most recounts of Hogwarts that I've read, doesn't think of Hogwarts as 'home'. In fact, she seems to be finding it akin to a prison, where she's "stuck inside". This of course lends to the title of the story, which I find awesome, by the way. I also found it particularly humorous that she had been witness to several events by accident, which have caused her turmoil over the years. Also, I think this opener sets up the remainder of the story nicely.

Enid is certainly a unique character. There was something specifically interesting about her thought process as she pursued Toby -- that he would wander off and die somewhere, losing points for her House and thus her friends. Not that this is an usual thought process for a young person, but it was the overall lack of concern for Toby that was motivating her is what made it stand out to me. I think that this is fantastic peak into Enid's characterization.

Of course, this changes slightly when Snape shows lack of consideration for her cat. Speaking of, I love the Snape/Hermione pairing weaved in here amidst Enid's reactions. I found myself really loving the brief moment between the two, while laughing at poor Enid's reaction. Of course, it was even more funny that the very next day she walked in on the Professors again.

I love the continuous trauma that poor Enid is undergoing as she endured the ongoing love affairs of Snape and Hermione. Of course, even at 13, thinking of or bearing witness to acts that contribute to your teacher's personal life isn't something that Enid would want to have to think about (or see, for that matter).

One of the biggest reasons that this is so much fun for me is that there's a beautiful, sentimental Snamione here, told from the eyes of a child who wishes she could be anywhere else, not witnessing this Snamione. It's SO sweet, the doubt in the relationship, Snape's remark about the reflection in the Mirror of Erised, and their growing relationship. Of course, the icing on the cake is Enid, hidden away in the corner, seeing the relationship in a new light (but still unsure exactly how she felt about that).

:D I love Enid's plan to avoid further witness to their love life -- just ask complicated questions about school and BAM! Sort of clever, actually.

So, the marriage, the pregnancy, and the revelation that they knew that she knew was all fantastic! I loved this so much! Also, your writing is excellent. And, once more, I enjoyed the romance interwoven into the humor.

Excellent piece!

 Report Review
If this is your story and you wish to respond to reviews, please login