What I don't understand is that Josephine can recall her memories. I was under the impression that ALL her memory was gone. Dumbledore performed the charm himself and he is the greatest wizard of their time. So if Josephine is recalling memories then Dumbledore didn't do a good enough job (which I'm finding hard to believe).
It is sort of like picking a couple of grapes off a large bunch and eating them. They're gone even though you knew they were once there. You can't recall them and eat them again. That's it, they're gone.
These bits about recalling memories just doesn't make sense to me. It sounds like you are questioning Dumbledore's abilities as a wizard and JKR as she created the theory behind memory wiping and memory charms.
Hmmm. Leaves you thinking a bit doesn't it??Author's Response: It's a good point. I went with the idea that something might have gone wrong and that even though memory wipes in the magical world are so very successful in completely wiping out memories, there are always outliers. Sasha just happens to be an outlier. She has some sort of residual memory that allows her to remember bits and pieces and eventually everything. Report Review
well i am going to say first that i LOVE IT!!! im sad its the last chapter though *Nina wiping away tears* It was cute when oliver handed her present!!! I love it so much!
Nina Report Review
Wow, just found this story, really like it! Hope you finish it, I really want to know what happens! :D Report Review
what the heck is it with sasha and finger thing now(claps her hands together) what abut chapter 4 I give it a 10 Report Review
I loved it! I can't wait for more!! Report Review
put the neixt chapter up Report Review
I will bug you untel you put the nexgt chapter up Report Review
Hi I just whated to say I love your story can you put the 2th chapter up love you :)Author's Response: i am sooo sorry! i'll get it up as soon as i can!! Report Review
I love the story can you put the next chapter UP!!!!!
i like this story. It's like another point of view...keep up the writing and update soon! Report Review
oooh i like the new re-write. good job! xoxpsychokitten Report Review
hey...great story so far...post more REALLY soon... Report Review
i liked it. im off to read the others now... Report Review
Terms of Service
categories & genres
short story collection