{reviewid: 2109332, reviewer: 'Boots'}
1st May 2009:
So cool! I suppose now I shall have to wait until the next chapter graces me with its appearance. I wait with baited breath...
Report Review |
{reviewid: 2109305, reviewer: 'Boots'}
1st May 2009:
As much as I love your writing...you have no sense of rhythm! The poetry is so-so, and makes up for it in amusement value. The music, on the other hand, makes me wince.
Other than that, love the story! Your writing is almost as good as the original.
Report Review |
{reviewid: 2107027, reviewer: 'Boots'}
27th April 2009:
Wow, you reference the HPLexicon a LOT. I was just reading that kelpie story, and you mention it a lot there too. Anyway, I like it so far. You have a reasonable explanation for his presence, and you do a good job of giving him a touch of personality already.
Report Review |
{reviewid: 1790558, reviewer: 'basilisk'}
14th January 2008:
Oh My God. You finally updated!! I started reading this story when I was 14 or 15 and now I'm 17..! :D Well, I guess it's worth the wait..atleast you didn't abandon this masterpiece of a story! I still didn't read the latest chapter but I'm so ecstatic that I HAD to give you this review!! I'll read it and give you another one! :P
P.S. You a published writer yet?!
Report Review |
{reviewid: 1725254, reviewer: 'cookiemonster'}
24th November 2007:
Love how Hermione takes a leaf out of the pranksters' book!
Author's Response: She's not as square as she seems - just needs a bit of a push :)
Report Review |
{reviewid: 1716291, reviewer: 'cookiemonster'}
18th November 2007:
Awesome story!
Author's Response: thanks :)
Report Review |
{reviewid: 1714452, reviewer: 'cookiemonster'}
17th November 2007:
Great chapter! One question- If the Black family knew that a star would bring them light, how come they kept naming their children after stars if they did not want to be good instead of evil? (did that make sense?)
Author's Response: it does. but the prophecy could also mean hope and not just light.
Report Review |
{reviewid: 1714422, reviewer: 'cookiemonster'}
17th November 2007:
Great, as usual!
Author's Response: thanks :)
Report Review |
{reviewid: 1714397, reviewer: 'cookiemonster'}
17th November 2007:
Great chappie! I love how Dumbledore only thinks the pranks are funny, not annoying.
Author's Response: he's probably the only one strange enough to think so *lol*
Report Review |
{reviewid: 1707315, reviewer: 'cookiemonster'}
11th November 2007:
Absolutely love it!
Author's Response: thank you. I appreciae the review
Report Review |
{reviewid: 1707298, reviewer: 'cookiemonster'}
11th November 2007:
Hilarious! I LOVE Sirius!
Author's Response: me too! :)
Report Review |
{reviewid: 1707277, reviewer: 'cookiemonster'}
11th November 2007:
Wow. Those memories were really moving.great job
Author's Response: thank you. appreciate you saying so. :)
Report Review |
{reviewid: 1706344, reviewer: 'cookiemonster'}
10th November 2007:
Great story! I like how Sirius patronizes McGonagall. I don't know if I'm over analyzing, but I noticed that Sirius called McGonagall a "steely eyed goddess." I'm assuming that you were associating her with Athena, greek goddess of wisdom, whom many said had flashing eyes. Am I right?
Author's Response: *L* You got it. Its just the name Minerva - Roman version of Athena and all :)
Report Review |
{reviewid: 1658505, reviewer: 'cookiemonster'}
7th October 2007:
Love it!
Author's Response: :)
Report Review |
{reviewid: 1650573, reviewer: 'cookiemonster'}
30th September 2007:
Great story
Author's Response: thank you.
Report Review |
{reviewid: 1650556, reviewer: 'cookiemonster'}
30th September 2007:
Great start! I'm really glad Sirius actually acts and talks like a six year-old, because I hate it when people write children that talk like adults...anyway, I love it!
Author's Response: Helps that I babysit so I know how kids talk :)
Report Review |
{reviewid: 1605706, reviewer: 'Bryguy'}
30th August 2007:
This is an amazing story so far.
The cool twists and the pranks are well thought up and the subtle interweaving of canon is excellent.
The only bad part of the story so far is it's not finished :)
Author's Response: I know. I really ought to get on with this :(
Report Review |
{reviewid: 1605601, reviewer: 'Siriusly%20Cool'}
30th August 2007:
There really were wolves that live in a rainforest? Who'd have thought. I love wolves. Canis Lupus is the coolest.
I'm waiting for Minerva to finally expell Sirius. Engagement invitations... That boy thinks of everything.
I'm enjoying this immensly, by the way.
Author's Response: :) I was amazed myself - imagine isolated in an island too. uber mysterious.
She can't *loI* Dumbledore won't let her! The old guy just enjoys it as much as Sirius does. *shakes head*
Report Review |
{reviewid: 1605535, reviewer: 'Siriusly%20Cool'}
30th August 2007:
No, you're not being Sirius... Sorry. Had to add that. Even though that is probably the oldest joke in all of fandom.
The horse names are great. They fit them so well, in sound and meaning.
I love the pranks. I don't know where you get them all from, they're great. I've always wondered what would happen if Sirius worked with Fred and George... Disaster.
I feel bad for the Marauders though... Prongs, Moony and Wormtail without Padfoot? Anyway, I'll read on.
Author's Response: I can't get enough of that old joke as well *lol*. The pranks? Just think of regular pranks and exagerrate them. :)
Report Review |
{reviewid: 1580641, reviewer: 'goodbyetoyou'}
17th August 2007:
I'm terribily sorry for not commenting on every chapter, but I am going away later today and wanted to finish you story. I think your story is original, funny, and really good. Keep up the terrific work!
Author's Response: well that's plenty of chapters. just happy to know you enjoyed this. Thanks for all your reviews a well as reading my other stories :)
Report Review |
{reviewid: 1580631, reviewer: 'goodbyetoyou'}
17th August 2007:
good chapter!
Author's Response: thanks
Report Review |
{reviewid: 1580627, reviewer: 'goodbyetoyou'}
17th August 2007:
good chapter. I loved the rules of pranking.
Author's Response: :) crazy twins ... the things they come up with.
Report Review |
{reviewid: 1580624, reviewer: 'goodbyetoyou'}
17th August 2007:
another great chapter. I'd say more but I cannot wait until I get to the next one
Author's Response: thanks I'm glad to know you're enjoying this
Report Review |
{reviewid: 1580617, reviewer: 'goodbyetoyou'}
17th August 2007:
the scene with McGonagall and Sirius was halrious. It made me laugh =D
Author's Response: poor Mcgonagall... Sirius is insane :)
Report Review |
{reviewid: 1580607, reviewer: 'goodbyetoyou'}
17th August 2007:
very nice. I like how you have him talking to his family through a book.
Author's Response: a mix of never ending story and the riddle diary :)
Report Review |