{reviewid: 2707709, reviewer: 'padmoonyfoot7'}
12th June 2012:
Absolutely AMAZING!! Really felt bad for him. I love the way you described the way a twelve year-old thinks, and went into great detail with comparisons between Hogwarts and the Parlor. You also described his feelings very well and showed how well he could read his mother.
Keep up the good work!!
padmoonyfoot7: over and out!!
Report Review |
{reviewid: 2562328, reviewer: 'alicia%20and%20anne'}
6th August 2011:
I felt sorry for Sirius in this, his mother isn't a nice person at all.
The description of the rooms and the way Sirius felt made me really feel like I was in the story with him, feeling what he was feeling and seeing what he was seeing.
You wrote this story beautifully and you described the Black family/household how I imagined them and it to be.
This was an extrememly good read.
alicia and anne
Slytherin
Report Review |
{reviewid: 2490514, reviewer: 'Mintleaf'}
7th March 2011:
This is wonderful and the perfect idea for a one-shot! Sans a couple of little errors this was one of my favorite short stories. The idea was fantastic and a perspective that's not looked at often enough! :)
Report Review |
{reviewid: 1001981, reviewer: 'ss10009'}
27th May 2006:
I felt the pain for him.
Great story! Excellent writing!
Two different people inside of him.
Report Review |
{reviewid: 936195, reviewer: 'RedRebel'}
13th March 2006:
Wow, Sirius's thoughts were deep....poor Sirius. I really like this...If I were signed in (slytheringinny) I'd put this in my favourites!
Report Review |
{reviewid: 862396, reviewer: 'HPismyidol'}
17th January 2006:
omg! so good. i <3<3<3<3<3 it update soon!
~meha
Report Review |
{reviewid: 752362, reviewer: 'WolfChild'}
29th October 2005:
Wonderful little one-shot! I loved how Sirius was portrayed, especially how he is like two different people, the school boy and the Black child. Great job!
Report Review |
{reviewid: 643242, reviewer: 'siriuschick4eva'}
12th August 2005:
aaaww poor Sirius!! His mom is messed up and cruel!! If I were him, I would want to do that to the carpet too.
Report Review |
{reviewid: 542698, reviewer: 'silver%20phoenix'}
13th June 2005:
Wow. This was brilliant. Thank Merlin for the "random story" button. I really enjoyed this--I think you caught our young, beloved Sirius perfectly.
Report Review |
{reviewid: 541146, reviewer: 'smilexkill'}
12th June 2005:
I really liked this, very discriptive. Really enjoyed his take on life in his home during his childhood and all that jazz.
Report Review |
{reviewid: 517808, reviewer: 'justice'}
27th May 2005:
pretty darn good
Report Review |
{reviewid: 501220, reviewer: 'sophie'}
14th May 2005:
this story is brilliant. It not only shows sirius' dislike of his home life, but it also shows it in a way that, i tink, everyone can realate too, not just deeply torubled teens or orphans.
Author's Response: Thank you very much!
And, thanks a lot to everyone who has reviewed so far. You all totally rock my multi-colored socks.
Report Review |
{reviewid: 500427, reviewer: 'TheFlamingPhoenix'}
14th May 2005:
Wow. I saw this story featured on the front page and I liked the desciption so I read it. Wow, I really really really loved this. I love the innocence of Sirius yet he also has the slight knowledge of his mother's true actions. I love it at. You did a brilliant job. It made me feel sad for him too... especially near the end. Good job!
Author's Response: Thank you very much.
Wait a minute, this story is featured on the front page? *this* one? Where?
Report Review |
{reviewid: 493155, reviewer: 'Shading%20in%20Grey'}
8th May 2005:
Wow! Really well-written, and convincing. Some lovely description here, and an accurate characterisation - imo - for the age of Sirius.
Report Review |
{reviewid: 490415, reviewer: 'Lily%20Evans'}
6th May 2005:
What a great fic. You certainly did a wonderful job. I think that you should definatly think of writing more Sirius fics since this one was written brilliantly. Keep up the fantastic work!
Report Review |
{reviewid: 483792, reviewer: 'Leah%20Weasly'}
1st May 2005:
i loved it! Sirius is my fave character, well was until he *sob* died...
Report Review |
{reviewid: 473871, reviewer: 'JAWorley'}
23rd April 2005:
Wow, that was awesome. That was just great. Well done, and nice observations. -JW.
Report Review |
{reviewid: 472546, reviewer: 'Meme'}
22nd April 2005:
Hm...... thatsa good1!
Report Review |
{reviewid: 471748, reviewer: 'Penny'}
21st April 2005:
I loved it, you described a young Sirius just how I imagined he would be and showed a different side of him. Please write more..
Report Review |
{reviewid: 468282, reviewer: 'MEJ18'}
19th April 2005:
I would like to hear more! It is has a wonderful hook and I would love more back story on Sirius. Good Job!
Report Review |
{reviewid: 460469, reviewer: 'Eideann%20Adenydd'}
14th April 2005:
Poor Sirius... Great story, very different. I enjoyed it.
Report Review |
{reviewid: 447243, reviewer: 'All_Canon'}
5th April 2005:
Fantastic. A spectacular chararacterization of Sirius. This is extremely high praise coming from someone who finds Sirius as her favorite character to both read and write about. You did an excellent job at paying attention to his age: a twelve year. The image of Sirius standing before a stuffed house elf is endearing and lasting. You also have a distinctive style of writing that I thoroughly enjoyed reading. I've added this piece to my list of favorites. Well done! Keep writing!
Report Review |
{reviewid: 439650, reviewer: 'MaraudersFan'}
1st April 2005:
Sorry, I didn't have time to log in, but I love your story! Will you be continuing it, or basing more stories off of it? I hope so! :)
Report Review |
{reviewid: 427330, reviewer: 'benfolds'}
24th March 2005:
that was really good.i liked it a lot.
Report Review |
{reviewid: 421978, reviewer: 'bluegirl'}
20th March 2005:
i like how you put alot of detail in the story. good job.
Report Review |