Reading Reviews for The Calendar Girls
61 Reviews Found

Review #1, by GalaxyDefender Hirrandipopping

3rd November 2015:
Next chapter next chapter next chapter next chapter please please please please please please please please please please please. This is such an amazing story, its got ms hooked. Itd be such a shame if you didn't finish the story. Plus I really need to find out how this ends, with the wands and all. And I've got a feeling that louis/autumn is a slow burner. Xxx Ps. Pleasessse update

Author's Response: Oh my god, this is such a nice surprise, thank you!

Unfortunately, while I'd love to suddenly pop out the rest of the story, I'm afraid that's not going to happen, at least not in the near future... Writing has sort of taken a backseat in my life right now and when I do come back to this website, TCG isn't the work I most want to write. I'm really sorry because I understand how frustrating it is to appreciate a story and to see it cut off abruptly, so I promise to try to come back to this, I just don't know when that'll be.

Thank you for the review, it really made my day and I'm so glad you like the story!

 Report Review

Review #2, by MissMdsty Hirrandipopping

21st October 2013:
Hey there! I came back for some Autumn/Louis goodies and I was not disappointed. But one thing at a time.

I loved how much detail the girls put into planning the birthday party. It's so amazing to see the kind of friendship these girls have. And having Dom and Roxanne as the Weasleys who are part of it is more amazing, because I feel like they get somewhat overlooked in NextGen stories. The stories about them growing up and the trouble they made. If I were their parents I'd always have some Veritaserum at hand to get the truth out of them. Or maybe Polyjuice Potions to infiltrate enemy ranks... Yeah that's me channeling my inner RtF feels.

I liked the bit about them saying they have super human hearing abilities, as opposed to just showing the others the map. It's things like these, where we know but the character doesn't that I really like. Although, Autumn should suspect something is up, history has shown us that Filch can be avoided only by map, cloak or Felix Felicis.

And Autumn and Louis oh the shippyness. Yes, I invented a word. No, I am not sorry, because you made me search for "Hirrandipopping" and I sat there in shame as all search results lead to your story. I feel like just slipping them some Amortentia or something and getting this show on the road. The romantic tension between them is something you can cut with a knife. Maybe don't give them Amortentia, give them Kissing Concoction. Knowing these characters though, they'd probably end up mixing Pepper Up Potion or something like it by accident, so scrap that whole plan.

I really liked getting back into the atmosphere of the girls' life at Hogwarts and their wacky adventures and I will proceed to poke you from time to time to update! *pokes*

Great chapter lovely! :)


Author's Response: RAL!

Rereading this review, I sat here blinking for about a minute before remembering the context in which it was written. ;)

The girls' friendship makes me so happy. I write their interactions with a huge, goofy smile every time. Roxanne and Dom do get overlooked most of the time, I agree -- it's part of the reason I chose to write about them (and also because I felt writing an original take on Rose would be difficult and I was lazy).

Autumn will find out about the map and cloak eventually! I just feel like the way everyone in Next Gen stories knows about them is odd and that Harry wouldn't want the entire world knowing.

Hahaha, I'm not sorry you had to google hirrandipopping! All credit goes to Sophie. And I'll be stealing shipyness, it looks funky. THERE WILL BE MORE SHIPPYNESS TO COME.

*pokes back*

Thank you darling! ♥

 Report Review

Review #3, by Courtney Dark Hirrandipopping

11th October 2013:
IT'S OKAY, I FORGIVE YOU FOR TAKING SUCH A LONG TIME!! I know from experience that a LOT of time can pass without you really realizing it, and then you're all 'OMG! HOW HAVE I NOT DONE THAT BY NOW?' etc, etc. Anyway, this chapter was cool, so I completely forgive you:) And I still need to find tome to read the next chapter of 'Reason to Fight'.

Anyway, I love all your characters, especially Dom because she just seems so awesome, confident and sassy. And I loved all the little details you added in about George's joke presents and the Weasley family - especially the diary. That made me laugh, because it definitely seems like a Weasley sort of thing to do.

If I was so Sophie, my friends would have no chance of throwing me a surprise birthday, because I've got such a bad temper that I would probably beat them round the head with a broomstick before they got the chance. Which just goes to show that Sophie is clearly a much nicer, more mellow person than me.

I'm looking forward to the next chapter, however long it takes!


Author's Response: COURTNEY, YAY!

I don't deserve the forgiveness. *throws self at your feet*

Dom is such a sassy mouth, I wish I could be more like her... And it's good that you like the mentions of the Weasley family, because I'm planning a big reunion with all the cousins, which should be fun (and also horrendous to write because large casts are the bane of my existence)!

I HAVE MENTAL IMAGES. I need to write a scene including someone getting beat around the head by a broomstick. I need to.

Thank you for being so lovely and patient and for leaving such awesome reviews! :3

 Report Review

Review #4, by slightlyobsessedwithfanfiction Hirrandipopping

1st October 2013:
Hell yeah i'm awesome!!! :P nah just kidding ...NOT.
Even though i'd already read it, i'm so happy you updated.. it was so nice to read.
But yeah, i WILL pelt you with tomatoes... so come all the way to England to make it easier :P Really, please come :)
Ok so loved the chapter and ladida. UPDATE MORE NOW :P . yes.. i know patience is a virtue.. but not when it comes to HARRY POTTER FAN FICTION!
So you go Guuurrlll. keep writing, and write fast!!
miss you :) (i really do)

Your "super awesome friend" Claire :) ... yup that's me.. where's maaa crown for bein so amazing Dawg?

Author's Response: Pshf, I have an anti-tomato shield anyway.

Patience is indeed a virtue, you know how terrible I am at updating. I'm trying to get seven written and posted asap, but it's not being cooperative. I'll probably bounce ideas off you again, so maybe you'll be more lenient with my bad updating skills!

(I miss you too, I want to come and visit but that's impossible, so we really need to plan something around Christmas!)

(I ATE YOUR CROWN. And found your constitution again.)


 Report Review

Review #5, by Jchrissy Celebrating

2nd August 2013:
Oh my god, Val, I seriously feel like i was just with all these women/girls for the day and I'm exhausted!!! You did such an awesome job showing their chaotic lives, and I loved the sarcastic/fun personality of Autumn.

I feel like people think large families has to be reserved for the Weasleys, so I LOVED that you gave us this awesome big family Christmas scene with an entirely separate family! Molly Weasley doesn't have the market on children, after all.

And of course you slid in some of your Frenchness into this, which I always love. That and the new adopted baby (who I hope we get to meet!) were awesome little details to help give us a good picture of this family and to open up the world a bit from the small Hogwarts tunnel we often get with next gen.

I'm such a sucker for Bill/Fleur (your grounded for that, btw) and their kids, that I loved seeing Dom as one of our MC. I hope ;). Everything about them felt very natural and like actual friends, not just characters you put together for the sake of plot. Also, do we get to go to France and visit Fleur and Louis?! PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE!

I really liked this first chapter, m'dear!

Author's Response: Trust me, that many females grouped together can only be exhausting (and I speak as a female too, random person hypothetically reading my response, so no need to get onto your feminist battle horse)!

People do seem to think that large families are only for the Weasleys, right? As someone who has a twenty first cousins, I wanted to recreate the sense of chaos and agitation that comes with family gatherings -- and come to think of it, this was quite mild compared to my family!

Yes, you do meet the adopted baby! (Also, of course there would be French, because I'm a snooty bilingual who likes to show off ;) )

I AM SORRY, PLEASE DON'T GROUND ME. But I've always felt that at least one Weasley couple would get a divorce (there's a 1/3 statistic, after all), and Ron and Hermione were overdone...

Thank you for the review, lovely!

 Report Review

Review #6, by academica Owling

16th June 2013:
Hi lovely ♥

Another cute chapter. I liked watching Autumn and Louis interact--it was sweet that he let her borrow his jacket because it's a classic romantic move. I also liked the letter because it gave us a glimpse of how things were going at home (something you don't often get with stories set at Hogwarts). It was nice to imagine Yuna settling into her new life.

The only thing I can really find to critique is that it feels like there isn't a central plot line tugging this along. Mostly what I've seen so far is lots of pranking, the beginnings of a romance between Autumn and Louis, and classic Hogwarts stuff like going to class and Quidditch games. I thought the situation with Fern going missing would be that little dash of mystery that tied everything together, but then she turned up, and so now the plot just seems a little bit aimless to me. Do you have something in mind for your next chapter to bring in some more action and give the story direction?

Nice work so far! As requested, I'll switch over to Reason to Fight next time it's my turn.


Author's Response: Okay this is getting answered before everything else because it's my four hundredth review!

You're absolutely right about there being no central plot, though I'm working on it, I promise. RL has just been getting perpetually in the way, and as someone tired of school, writing school scenes was horrible, as it didn't leave me much space to run away from reality for a moment, if that makes sense. But yes, there should be something to center the plot on, and it should be coming in future chapters, though I'm not sure when they'll be posted...

Thank you so much for your advice, I'll be getting back to Post Scriptum asap!

 Report Review

Review #7, by ShadowRose Snowballing

22nd May 2013:
Hello again!

Yay, we found Fern! I didn't actually realize that at first, but then I saw she was on the list for snowball fights. I still worry about her though... Also, her relationship with Peeves is kind of cool. It's interesting to see Peeves actually care about someone, especially considering it was someone who yelled at him for something completely random.

James is an... interesting character. You can really tell that he's a bit of a softie, what with his whole buddy system thing, but he's also got quite a bit of an ego, since he's unwilling to go public with Lorcan (speaking of which, she's so often a male in fanfiction that it kind of surprised me a bit when she was with James :P ).

The requirements for Charlie's girlfriend was hilarious. Given he's the only Weasley that never settle down, it would make sense that the entire clan is trying to find him a girl that is absolutely perfect.

I don't really think you need to apologize for the amount of "academic" stuff you talk about in this. After all, they're at school, so academic stuff is kind of the centre of their lives. Naturally it has to be present in at least some part of the story to keep it realistic. :)

I love the DADA scene especially, because it really shows what a team Summer and Autumn are. It also kind of shows their character, in that Summer is the more offensive one, and Autumn is more defensive, which parallels their personalities. I'm trying to decide if Professor Bones's comment about Autumn having to be the offensive one is foreshadowing or not... :P

Aw, yay, Autumn and Louis! Except, of course, Louis is being a little chicken about it and acting like it was just to get other girls off his back. I really am excited to see how their relationship plays out. I think it's interesting that Louis is younger than Autumn here, because it's often seen the other way around, but the guy usually isn't younger than the girl. I like the change of pace though. :)

"That's a terrible name for your family mafia."

Once again, Autumn's sense of humour gets to me... I mean, who calls a family a gang? :D Also, PEASTERLY. That's kind of hilarious, and a nice change from Wotter and Peasley.

I love that Dom hints at Louis's interest in Autumn, but then drops it. Foreshadowing is my fave. :P

I know that the "running-into-the-other-person-thing" (I don't think that makes sense, oh well...) is possibly considered a cliche, but personally, I run into people all the time, so I wouldn't consider it to be cliche, considering it's actually quite common.

Overall, I love the sense of humour you have going on with this story, so feel free to re-request for the later chapters! :)

-ShadowRose (Taylor)

Author's Response: Hi Taylor!

I think Peeves respects Fern precisely for yelling something so random at him. It's honestly one of my favourite friendships in this entire story, if you must know.

Ah, James. He's very protective of his family, but he's also quite self-conscious. Unfortunately for Lorcan, she doesn't ft with the image of himself he wants to project. I sort of despise him for that aspect of his personality (why I wrote him like that, I have no idea).

I'm so happy you picked up on how the duel parallels the twins' personalities! As for the foreshadowing, my lips are sealed ;)

Of course Louis is being a chicken, Autumn is his little sister's best friend and she's blissfully oblivious! Louis is older than Autumn though...

Peasterly has me cackling everytime I type it, I'm happy it does the same for you!

And yes, Dom likes foreshadowing too.

Thank you so much for yet another lovely review, and I'm sorry it took so long to get back to you :)

 Report Review

Review #8, by ShadowRose Gambling

22nd May 2013:
I'm back. :)

Oh dear, where'd Fern go? That's certainly not good. Stop ending these chapters on cliffies, GAH, because I have to wait until I finish writing the review to go on to the next chapter and figure out what on earth is going on. I'm just kidding, though, because I love cliff-hangers, and these are just dramatic enough to create interest, but not overly so either.

I love how you're managing to weave both interactions with the Potter/Weasley family and interactions with Autumn's own family into this. It's a really nice balance, and refreshing from stories that totally and completely center on just the Wotter (gosh I love that word...) family.

Another thing you manage to combine really excellently in this story is the main humour element and some very serious topics as well, like Bill and Fleur's divorce, the Seasons girls runaway father, and Emily and Newton's inability to have children.

I love how Professor Clearwater and Chang have kind of switched places since their Hogwarts days, because back then it would seem that Penelope would be the more structured one. But hey, that just shows how much people can change after their school days.

I love that Summer just strolled into the Ravenclaw common room. It kind of shows how similar she is to Autumn in that they both have that Ravenclaw trait in them, yet different at the same time, as seen in her inability to keep track of her shoes, and her little gambling problem.

That egg-thing that Autumn found in her closet was strange... I wonder if that has anything to do with where Fern is, considering she was inside of it? Oh well, I guess I'll find out soon enough. :)

This chapter flowed really well through the different scenes too. The one little thing I saw was the jump from the flashback at the start to Summer sitting in the common room. It felt a little bit jarring right there, although that could easily be fixed with a little sentence of transition or something of the sort. :)

I like that you included actual lessons in this, because I think the lessons are some of the most fascinating parts of Hogwarts (why yes, I am being very Hermione-esque right now), so it's fun to see other writers' takes on them. Turning a turtle into a pillow? What? Hahahah that has no real life application, but hey, it's Hogwarts. :P

"It's not because you're as slow as a fat kid on crutches that I have to be as well."

OH MY GOSH I actually laughed out loud at this line. It's so Summer, and completely unexpected.

"Stop looking like the receptionist of a funeral parlour."

Well, that's always a good way to cheer someone up. But I like this line because it shows that Summer and Autumn have the same odd sense of humour.

I have one little canon-ness comment. When you're talking about people asking if Fred had a tattoo of a hippogriff, I think Ginny said that Harry had the Hungarian Horntail, and Ron was the one who had a tattoo of a Pygmy Puff. I don't even know why I remember that...

Anyways, another really great chapter!

-ShadowRose (Taylor)

Author's Response: I am a disgrace, it has been almost two months.

Sorry about the cliffhanger (actually no, cue evil cackling). I cannot say about Fern, as tempted as I am...

I prefer Peasterly to Wotter, but any combination is fun! Writing them is turning out to be a lot more difficult than I thought, as they're a huge group, but it's good to hear you think it's working out well.

I don't think Clearwater lacks structure, I just see her as the more motherly type -- I had a bit of an issue with Cho until not so long ago, which has influenced my writing and made her the strict teacher.

Summer and Autumn are very similar, yes, except that the latter is more sensible than the former. I think Summer would have made an excellent Gryffindor, except that that house is overrated and I didn't want to stick any OCs in there.

I get so annoyed with Next Gen fics that ignore classes. What do.people thknk Hogwarts is, a dating platform? Plus it's actually fun to invent what people might study. And turning turtles into pillows is VERY USEFUL, THANK YOU VERY MUCH. I use it every day. :P

I'll correct the tatoo mix-up as soon as I can.

Thank you for the review :)

 Report Review

Review #9, by ShadowRose Celebrating

22nd May 2013:
Sorry for the delay, but I'm finally here with your requested review!

First of all, the character names are BRILLIANT. By the time you got to their middle names, I was practically falling out of my chair laughing. I mean,
Autumn Jonquil? How unfortunate. :P

I like how even though the sisters are similar, you've already established their own individual personalities. Fern's the artist, Ivy wants to be a Healer, and so on. I also like that you managed to throw pieces of information like that into the story without stating it outright, but by mentioning little things as the chapter goes on.

I love how the Weasley/Potter family is so distributed across the four Houses, and also I think it's interesting that Bill and Fleur are divorced. I feel like the Ron/Hermione divorce scenario has been beat to a pulp, so it's refreshing to see it happen to a different couple. Wow, I totally didn't mean for that to sound like I support divorce, but, I mean, given the current divorce rate, it makes sense that one of the couples would divorce.

I like how there's already been quite a bit going on in this first chapter, instead of it simply being an introduction with no action. I still get the feeling that I've been properly introduced to all of the characters, but at the same time, I didn't have to wade through paragraph after paragraph of physical descriptions or anything like that. Instead, they came naturally.

This whole chapter flowed really well, even though it did manage to go through quite a few different scenes.

Another thing I LOVED was Roger and Noah. They're so funny, and it was an interesting way of throwing some slash into the mixture without it being a full-on slash story.

I also think it's cool that you brought Sophie's Muggle brother and physics into the mix. I love that they're trying to study the crossroads between science and magic, because that's something I've always wondered about.

Let's see, favourite lines:

"But as you've realised, sanity is a relative concept in our family."

An awesome transition into the next scene, and really funny too.

"It was only then that we were capable of having a full conversation, because we didn't have the option of leaving in a huff, slamming the door as we left.

Ivy has tried. Once."

Oh gosh, considering my friends and I were discussing how to exit a moving vehicle the other day, this line cracked me up too. :D

So far, this all seems pretty Hogwart-y (speaking of which, I like that word... I may start using it more in reviews) and I didn't find any glaring cliches yet.

Oh gosh, I feel like I'm supposed to wrap up a squee-ing review like this with at least some constructive criticism, but GAH, I can't find anything. Although I guess that's a good thing, now isn't it? :)

Awesome first chapter, and I'm looking forward to the next ones!

-ShadowRose (Taylor)

Author's Response: Hi! Massive apologies for the delay in responding...

I'm glad you like the names! Originally, I was going to write a parody, but this was the result instead.

The Ron/Hermione divorce really has been beaten to a pulp, hasn't it? Bill and Fleur came as an obvious answer, I suppose. For me, it made sense that at least one Weasley couple would split up eventually, and I couldn't find any other for whom a divroce would make sense...

Ah, Roger and Noah! Their inclusion follows the inclusion of a divorce (in my head anyway) because I feel like the portrayal of families in fanfiction is very two-dimensional: either you've got perfect families or abusive ones. There seems to be no middle, you know?

Hahaha you picked up on some of my favourite lines :)

No worries, squeeing reviews are fine by me, and thank you very much for this one, it made me very happy!

 Report Review

Review #10, by PitchBlue Gambling

16th May 2013:
Hello again!

Great, great, great. I like how you portray daily life and conversations, it's so easy to relate to that. I was surprised about the turn at the end of the chapter, when they mentioned nobody had seen Fern - you got me very curious there. Also, I looked up the song and I adore it! So great! Really, I did a little dance on my seat, I feel like a complete nutter. Now, I'm going to listen to the song a few thousand times more and start reading your next chapter.

- PB

Author's Response: Hi!

I'm glad you find the characters relatable, as it's one of my main objectives with this story. And Fern is quite the mystery, isn't she?

Ah, that song! I'm glad you like it!

Thank you for the review :)

 Report Review

Review #11, by PitchBlue Celebrating

16th May 2013:

I really like this chapter. It's funny, fresh, easy - going. All the different names confused me a bit in the beginning though, but then again I'm rather slow. Your characters seem well thought - out as far as I can tell from the first chapter, I'm curious about them. I was very sad when you mentioned Bill and Fleur being divorced, I always thought they were so great :( So, I'm going to continue reading, lovely first chapter!

- PB

Author's Response: Hi!

Yeah, the names are a bit of a mouthful at first, but hopefully the next chapters make things a bit clearer?

Bill and Fleur divorced made me sad too, but I felt that stastically one of the Weasley couples would be divorced, and Hermione/Ron was overused. That really makes me sound like a stone-hearted person, doesn't it?

Thank you for the lovely review, I hope you enjoy the following chapters!

 Report Review

Review #12, by teh tarik Walking

1st May 2013:
Hello Val :) Erm, you requested a review from me nearly a month ago...*sheepish*. Well, here I am. Ooh, you're the second person who's requested for a chapter in the middle of the story :) I offer this in my original topic, but many requesters don't make use of this. Anyway, I'll do my best to comment on and critique this chapter without knowing any of the backstory and such.

You have a really lovely writing style; your writing is clear, sharp and concise. Your characters are fun to read and are engaging, and the interactions between them are lively and exciting. I really loved the sisters' relationships with each other - they're close; they're affectionate and light-hearted and bossy and ever so supportive of each other. But from what I've read, they're not all stuck together - Autumn does have her own life with her friends, and she does have Louis to occupy her time as well. The date between Louis and Autumn was simply lovely; I loved that they explored the workshop of Weasley's Wizard Wheezes. It certainly is a fitting location and it provides that perfect humorous joke-y atmosphere for their date.

The conversation between them about traditions was written wonderfully. It's cheerful and fluffy, but it still reveals things about the characters e.g. Autumn's attitude toward dating and relationships and romance. She certainly falls on the more traditional side :) And that does fit with the conventions of the romance genre; there's usually that sense of tradition, the need for a relationship to progress along a series of steps before becoming established. I would like to see a little experimentation with moods and with different sides to the Louis/Autumn relationship e.g. the less pleasant moments, the conflicts etc. I'm sure there'll be plenty of these in future chapters :)

I think one of your writing strengths is dialogue. The dialogue is quick and witty and sharp and it really sparkles. Not many writers can write a wonderful and funny dialogue scene without sounding too forced - but your dialogue is so natural with a nice lovely flow, so well done.

Some critique (and I hope you don't mind, but I tend to be more critical in requested reviews): this is a fairly fast-paced chapter - there is a lot of movement through time, and there are many different sections jumping ahead, which sort of weakens the focus of the plot (because your story certainly does have a plot - an interesting one, too). What I'm trying to say is that there might be too many things in this chapter. I do feel that some of the scenes don't cohere too well, and some of them aren't quite necessary e.g. the first bit about the girls picking out an outfit for Autumn. Later there's another scene of the girls picking out yet another outfit for her. I think you definitely don't need two such similar scenes within the same chapter, because it can be a bit repetitive. You've already shown us that Autumn has an inability to dress with acceptable style ^.^

What I would suggest about the numerous sections is to perhaps really focus on two or three main events, e.g. the date and the party with the strange magic part at the end, and really elaborate on those scenes a little. Include a little more description to break up the long dialogue segments, to perhaps give a sense of the setting, or how the characters orientate themselves within their environment. Hope I'm not confusing you!

Anyway, I found that last bit with the strange magic parts really intriguing! I've never read anything like that in fanfic, so great work for originality. It's so refreshing to read a humour/romance/YA next gen fic set in Hogwarts with a nice touch of mystery and strange happenings. So many fanfic writers tend to forget how magical Hogwarts is, and they don't make full use of the wonderful setting. So I'm so glad to see this bit of mystery magic in your story. This was a great way to end the chapter. Just ♥ how Louis' wolf patronus pops out of Autumn's wand like that :) Maybe someday in the future it will be herself reciting that charm, and the wolf will pop out of her wand by itself. Because Autumn/Louis. Is such a cute ship. Auouis is a wonderful ship name, by the way. It sounds French.

Great writing, Val! Thanks for requesting and massive apologies for the delay :)


Author's Response: Hi teh! No worries about time, I understand that RL comes first -- how sad, isn't it?

I'm very happy you picked up on the relationships between the characters, because it's really something I wanted the story to center on, and not just in terms of ships.

Autumn is definitely on the traditional side, more than she'd like... She and Louis aren't actually dating yet, but there will also be less pleasant moments, of course.

Of course I don't mind criticism! If I did, I probably wouldn't even bother with Internet. Your point about this being fast-paced was already made on another chapter, and I thought this one was reasonably slow, but I'll definitely see where I can slow things down a bit, and where I can make transitions smoother.

However, the scene with the magic at the end is deliberately confusing, because it's an important part of the plot and I want the reader as confused as the characters for now -- does that make any sense?

Hm, as for Autumn's Patronus, well, my lips are sealed as well!

Thank you for the lovely detailed review, and again no need to apologise about the delay :)

 Report Review

Review #13, by 800 words of heaven Snowballing

28th April 2013:
Um... so when did you request this review from me? Was it over a month ago? Perhaps... but better late than never, right? *smiles hopefully*

Okay, so Fern still appears to be lost, and I get that how in different Houses and stuff, you tend to lose track of people, but is it not weird that you forgot THAT YOUR YOUNGER SISTER IS MISSING?!?! Perhaps that's just me. Also, kudos to them for doing homework on a Friday night! I don't do homework until Sunday night if I can help it!

Haha, the Potter-Weasley get-together and buddy system is a cute idea. And it's even more adorable because James thought it up!

I actually love the Weasley-Potter family dynamics you've set up here! They seem like a loud, rowdy, tight-knit bunch of people and there's only one way to describe them - adorable!

I really liked the way you wrote the duelling scene in this. It was succinct, and to the point, which really helped to keep the pace up, and illustrate the speed at which duels probably occur.

So, Lorcan is a girl? I had always assumed that she was a he, so I was super confused for a second there. And respect for James just went down, like ten notches! He shouldn't care what other people think of him and his relationships!


AND OMG LOUIS YOU SLY DOG! I actually haven't formed an opinion on him yet - must learn more about him! Hopefully, the next chapter is the "date" and we learn more about him? And why he chose Autumn?


No, it's not just you! I think Autumn just has quite a lot on her mind, and she's used to not seeing Fern for some time, but two weeks is a max before a big worrying phase.

Haha, I never do homework on Friday evenings. I probably should, but I've got the self-motivation of a piece of aspargus.

Potter/Weasley dynamics are nice to write about, even though this isn't focused on them. I do try to include some regularly though!

Yep, Lorcan is a girl -- I understand your confusion :) James is a bit too worried about the way people see him, isn't he? He is a fundamentally nice guy even though he's a bit of a manipulator.

LOUIS IS A SLY DOG INDEED! Yes, the next chapter is the date, I hope you'll like it. Thank you for the review :)

 Report Review

Review #14, by academica Walking

23rd April 2013:
A few unrelated notes--one, Hunter Parrish is super foxy and half the reason why I watched Weeds. Two, kind of excited about your new Cormac/Eloise.

ANYWHO. I'm back again to catch up!

I think Louis' little outing with Autumn was just adorable. What woman wouldn't fall for a guy who got her a ticket backstage to the Weasleys' private workshop? I liked how you took your time describing the different products and their effects and didn't rush through the "date" or force anything too romantic on the pair just yet. I have to wonder if the wand thing is indicative of their synergy or if it suggests something more diabolical.

Hmm, so is Scorpius the reason that Fern has been MIA so much lately? I can imagine her sneaking off to be with him. Still, I have to ask--should I be ready for a less pleasant secret to come out later?

I liked the party, too; it was nice that you made an effort not to include alcohol or ridiculous romantic escapades. I also liked how your description made me feel like I was right there in the room with them. I didn't feel like the dress description was overdone.

Very nice job, Val!


Author's Response: Yes Hunter Parrish. I hesitated about choosing him for Louis, but then I was just 'BAH WHATEVER'. It was one of my most intelligent rash decisions.

I don't think any woman could refuse, could they? I certainly wouldn't. The reason why nothing is too romantic yet is because Autumn is a little clueless about this type of thing.

Scorpius is part of it, but not the only reason! And to answer your question, well, I like to throw readers off balance...

Thank you for the review, I'll be getting back to Post Scriptum soon!

 Report Review

Review #15, by academica Snowballing

18th April 2013:
Hi Val! Here's the first of the two reviews I owe you. I'll be back sometime soon to do the other one.

Gosh, where is Fern?! You're making me nervous...

Anyway, I love the discussion of the Weasley antics and the strict list of qualifications for Charlie's girlfriends. I imagine he would be a tough one to get to settle down, so only the very best will do :)

Okay, I have to be honest--I have trouble picturing Peeves being at all serious. Caring about someone--perhaps, but I don't know if he'd let on about it. I would have pictured that interaction more like him continuing to make jokes and then showing through the action of trying to find her (behind the scenes, of course) that he cared. Does that make sense? I can see that you tried to justify it, though, so I guess this just comes down to a difference between tastes.

...oh, wait, so we did find Fern? That was abrupt. It's good that we've located her, though the way she's acting worries me a little. I'll stay tuned.

Hmm, does Louis have a thing for Autumn and is just trying to hide it? Interesting. I'll look forward to seeing how their "date" in Hogsmeade goes.

Okay, now that my running review is done, I want to comment on a few things I liked about this chapter. One is the sense of normalcy--I wouldn't even apologize about the academic content, because you're right, they're at school and it's good to show them actually going to class. Plus, it breaks up the action and creates interesting new scenes. Speaking of action, I also like how smoothly yours flows. I avoid action sequences like the plague because I can't figure out how to do that well, and yet it seemed to work well for you.

This is coming along nicely, Val!


Author's Response: Hi Amanda!

Fern is a mystery, and sadly I won't say anything about it because I'm keeping it a secret. You find out very soon though...

The Weasley antics are lovely to write about, I'm happy you liked that! Only the best one will do, yes -- if the women in his family let anyone get close enough :)

It's an interesting point you raise about the scene with Peeves, and I think I will edit sometime in the near future. I'm going to include a scene with Peeves again that sort of develops this one, so I hope it'll help clear up certain things.

Yep, we sort of found Fern! She let herself be found would be a more appropriate description though... I'm aware that was abrupt, but it was done on purpose. As I said, Fern's random appearances and disappearances are a big part of the story, so it's sealed lips for a few more chapters!

I'm happy you found this chapter normal, it's one of my big objectives with this story. Thank you for your lovely review :)

 Report Review

Review #16, by Siriusly89 Snowballing

13th April 2013:
Hello! Siriusly89 here with your very, very, very late review (Iím so sorry!)

Anyway, Iím here, ready to review!

I love how Ton just forgot about her sister for a whole week, although to be fair, Hogwarts sounds like a pretty big place (its massive) so, really her not seeing her sister for a week isnít such an alien idea after all. Huh, who knew?

The conversation about the Weasleyís get-together is so plausible, I can actually see it happening! Ahahahaha, Ginny fell off her chair. . . . .ha. . . . .

Summer and Autumn tag-teaming poor Matthew and Henry didnít seem all that fair to me, never mess with two women, especially when they know each other inside out and thus can cover each others weak spots, its inviting them to hand you your butt on a platter.

I love Matthew, Henry and Summer together. They are not allowed go out with each other, or anyone else. They are just to stay best friends, and wash each others socks. Okay? Good.

Awh. . . .. you got my hopes up there for a minute. I thought Lorcan was a boy, because I love the idea of gay James, heíd be like a very camp Sirius! Out of all the Next-Gen-ers, I always felt like either James or Louis would turn out to be gay. . . .

Ah well, you canít have everything. Lorcan sounds like good fun though, doesnít she? Maybe she could make more appearances later? Please?

Itís snowing in September? Or have we jumped forward in time and I just havenít noticed? Itís more than likely me. . . .

We jumped forward in time. Knew it1 I am a genius! Well, not really, but anyway!

Aah! Autumn and Louis are going to Hogsmeade together! I think I know whatís going to happen. . . . .. .

Autumn and Louis sittiní in a tree,

Feel free to re-request, I promise it wonít take as long next time.

Author's Response: It's not so much forgets as has a billion other things to think about, and now your comment has my brain buzzing with a plunny of someone who gets lost inside Hogwarts and never finds his way out muahaha.

Ahem. Yes, poor Ginny. And poor Matthew and Henry, they didn't stand a chance. And yes, they will wash each other's socks for the reast of their lives. I promise.

Haha, yeah, we moved through time.

K-I-S-S-I-N-G? Maybe, maybe not!

Thank you for your review, and no apologies are required honestly!


 Report Review

Review #17, by Courtney Dark Owling

10th April 2013:
This was another cool chapter - it's been so long since I read the first couple of chapters that I forgot about Noah and the rest of the family, but this chapter triggered my memory and reminded me how much I love him - I really hope we get to see him again soon!

Nice idea for Sophia's party - I'm definitely looking forward to reading that chapter. I just hope she doesn't get mad that her best friends have 'forgotten' her birthday.

And before I go (sorry for the super brief review, but I loved everything about this chapter, and I can't exactly type out the whole chapter in my review and say 'OMG! I loved this line!' Sorry for the random tangent) I would like to say again I LOVE LOUIS! His dance with Autumn was so perfectly adorable and I loved that little bit of awkwardness at the end.

Very nice job on this chapter! I can't wait to read more.


Author's Response: Yes we do see Noah again soon, actually -- though the circumstances may not be too happy, but anyway.

Sophie's party is all written out already, and i have anew story in the queue but after that chapter six of this is going up.

TEEHEE, YES, AWKWARDNESS. That's what they're all about :)

Thank you Courtney!

 Report Review

Review #18, by Courtney Dark Walking

10th April 2013:
This was another really fun chapter to read, and I love the way you are developing your characters.

Louis is just so adorable! I'm tempted to say he's my favourite character - I loved how original his date with Autumn was. It was so refreshing and different to read. In fact, nothing about your story is predictable or cliche which is great! And I actually like the fact that Scorpius asked Fern out, despite the fact that I absolutely love Rose and Scorpius.

Hehehe, I loved the idea of the Ravenclaw only party! It seemed like it would be a pretty relaxed, comfortable sort of scene, and I laughed at the reference to the Gryffindor parties where the girls ended up getting pregnant. Typical Gryffindors!

Oooh, that end bit was very mysterious! I'm wondering now if it has something to do with whatever is happening to Fern. I'm more curious than ever!


Author's Response: Feel free to say Louis' your favourite, he's (one of) mine too! I'm happy you liked the date, and Ferpius too -- though I'm a big Scorose fan as well!

Typical Gryffindors indeed! No, I like Gryffindors, it's just that all teen pregnancies seem to be about Gryffindor girls getting drunk at parties and ending up pregnant. I will read a story about a pregnant Hufflepuff, now that'd be different...

Perhaps it does have something to do with Fern, perhaps not! I swear all will be revealed one day, but not just yet.

Thank you for another of your wonderful reviews :)

 Report Review

Review #19, by Courtney Dark Snowballing

10th April 2013:
Hey there! Sorry it's been so long since I've read and reviewed, it really seems as though I have no time for reading fanfiction these days (sob!) But I wanted to spend my time on your fantabulous story!

Okay, this review isn't going to be super long because I really want to keep reading. I am so curious about Fern - where is she going, if anywhere? Has something happened to her? I can't wait to find out the answers! And her friendship with Peeves is so cute, and I've never seen anything like that done before! I definitely think it adds an original twinge to your story.

I actually like the fact that there is so much schoolwork in your story because, lets be honest, that's what school is about! There is not as much socializing and partying as many people make it out to be, so I am super happy to see that you are actually including the classes in your chapters. And that's part of the magic of Hogwarts, too - all the different classes and kinds of spells.

Finally, I had a feeling something with Louis and Autumn was going on, and the last little scene with them was perfect! I'm looking forward to seeing what happens in Hogsmeade.


Author's Response: Courtney!

No need to apologise, honestly -- RL getting in the way of fanfic is really irritating, and I've found myself sobbing more than once too!

Fern is a mystery that you will find out about later, but I won't say anything there because it's an important part of the plot. I'm happy you like her friendship with Peeves!

The reason I include so much schoolwork is because I went sifting through the forums and there was a thread of stereotypes that irritate the reader. One that often came back was 'all Next Gen ever does is party', so I went down the other road with this story! I'm also not a big party person myself, and writing about something you're unfamiliar with is difficult...

Louis and Autumn, no, I have no idea what you're on about.

Thank you for your review :)

 Report Review

Review #20, by academica Gambling

7th April 2013:
Hi Val! Back with another swappity-swap review :)

I kind of love Summer in this chapter. It was so funny how she matter-of-factly answered the Ravenclaw riddle and strode right into the common room. In that first section, I also liked how you went back to the Bill-Fleur divorce. Is that going to be a major theme in the story? It's interesting to see how Dominique and Louis are dealing with the divorce in different ways, though I do feel bad for Dominique taking her mother dating so hard. (And it's so funny to see someone else's depiction of Dominique after having written my own.)

It seemed a little odd for the girls to refer to Harry, Ginny, and Fleur by their first names. I would have at least expected to see last names tacked on. Maybe consider taking a second look at that?

Points for actually including a lesson in your chapter. It was funny to imagine a class full of students trying to turn turtles into pillows, and I like how the girls were gossiping about their professor's little history with Percy. Seems realistic.

I think it's cute that the girls are being a little risky in trying to band together to buy the purse for their mother. She's lucky to have such thoughtful daughters, though they must have been a handful growing up, especially with her being a single mom!

The only other part I would consider looking at here is the beginning, with Autumn recalling her Sorting. I think the transition there to the common room was a little abrupt. For a moment, I thought Summer had basically ignored her cheering new housemates and plopped down at the Ravenclaw table to demand the return of her shoes. I think you could put a brief remark in there about Autumn clearing her head and focusing on Summer, just to differentiate the scenes more.

Nice work again this chapter, and I'm looking forward to continuing--and seeing what happened to poor Fern!


Author's Response: Hi Amanda!

The point of Summer strolling in so easily was there for me to show that she and Autumn are not just similar physically, but also in their values and way of thinking. The fact that Autumn is reasonable when Summer is hot-headed, and that they're in different houses, don't make such a fundamental difference.

Bill and Fleur's divorce isn't going to be a big theme, but it helps explain some of Dom's relation with Louis. I also included it because all Weasley couples always seem to be blissfully married, and I wanted to show it wasn't necessarily the case. Dom, I think, is still very much a child, even though she swears a lot and tries to act tougher than she is -- deep down, she only wants her parents to be together and to be able to see her mum without feeling like she's betraying her dad.

And yes, I know that feeling!

The use of first names, well. This actually came from experience -- my mum always used to grumble when 'Aunt' was tacked in front of her name (apparently it made her sound old), and I imagined the Weasley women to have similar reactions. Thus, there goes the Aunt and Uncle business, and that's why I had the girls refer to their family only with first names. Does this even make sense?

I'm so happy you mentioned the classes! To be honest, I went searching through the stereotypes-you-hate topic on the forums, and a recurring one was 'There are no classes in Next Gen, all they seem to do is party', so I'm attempting to stay away from that.

The first scene of the previous chapter proves that not only they were a handful before, but still are sometimes. I really want to keep Ellen as a big part of this story, because there are so many stories where parents are presented as horrible people. Again, I just want them to have a relatively normal family (minus the fact that their father left, obviously), so their mother and uncles will keep appearing in and out...

I went back to reread the chapter after you commented on that introduction scene, and yes, it could definitely do with some fleshing out! I'll see how I can edit.

Thank you for yet another lovely review, I'll be around for chapter two of Post Scriptum sometime during the week :)

 Report Review

Review #21, by RavenclawGirl11 Owling

7th April 2013:
Yep, amazing. I think it would be funny if Yuna hates Autumn
~Macy x

Author's Response: Aww, thank you! I'll have to think about Yuna and Autumn's relationship, but for now, Yuna is less than a year old, so she shouldn't be able to do anything too mean yet...

 Report Review

Review #22, by RavenclawGirl11 Walking

7th April 2013:
Very very good chapter x
Can't wait to see what happens with Louis and Autumn (Lutumn)
~Macy x

Author's Response: Haha, I've got them as Loutumn, but that works too! Thank you for the review :)

 Report Review

Review #23, by RavenclawGirl11 Snowballing

7th April 2013:
Told you Louis and Autumn are meant to be!
~Macy x

Author's Response: I won't say anything so I don't spoil the story, but I'm sure you can figure it out :) Thanks for the review!

 Report Review

Review #24, by RavenclawGirl11 Gambling

7th April 2013:
I love this chapter, because this story is U N I Q U E
I think Louis and Autumn should start dating because yes they seem close and he seems sweet.

I think turtle/pillow thing seems something that hogwarts would teach (its mental, why would you change a turtle into a pillow? But its Hogwarts)

~Macy x

Author's Response: Thank you so much! No worries, Louis and Autumn will see sense reasonably soon.

True, there's no point in turning turtles into pillows, but hey. Glad you liked it!

 Report Review

Review #25, by RavenclawGirl11 Celebrating

7th April 2013:
Hey, good start enjoyed. Not going to say much because wanna read next chapter.
~Macy x

Author's Response: Hi, and thank you for the review! I hope you enjoy chapter 2 :)

 Report Review
If this is your story and you wish to respond to reviews, please login

<Previous Page  Jump:     Next Page>