Reading Reviews for Broken Values
  
6 Reviews Found

Review #1, by Bobby Dazzler Draco Malfoy

20th May 2013:
Hey Claire, how're you going today? :)

So, either I haven't had quite enough coffee today (up all night with a toddler with the flu, eurgh!) that my brain is misfiring or I missed something in the timeline of this story and that of DH and they're not quite matching up in my brain. It starts off at the manor when Bellatrix is torturing Hermione, but towards the end it mentions the Room of Requirement where Crabbe tried to kill Harry? Granted, it's been a few years since I read the book (and only the once... SHAME!), but even in movie timeline which is still pretty accurate, I thought that occurred after the Manor scene. So... my question is, how much coffee do I need for it to make sense in my brain today? lol. Nah, my question is did Draco just keep a running inner monologue going as the canon story progressed, or am I just missing the entire plot this time around? If it's the latter, I'm so so sorry and I will go chain myself to the coffee pot!

I thought writing wise it was beautiful, no spelling or grammar mistakes that I could see and it made for flawless easy reading (minus the Kate-confusion), and the imagery of what you were saying was quite clear and packed a punch. I could really see the silver crest of Malfoy in my mind for some reason, it definitely stuck in my mind.

I am unfamiliar with the song! I'll have to get on youtube and have a look I think, might make things fall into place for me a little better, but aside from my general fuzzy-brained insanity, I thought it was a nice story and a good insight into the very troubled mind of Malfoy :)

Author's Response: Thank you for your lovely review!
And sorry for the confusion, but it's more of a running monologue rather than specifically where he is. Sorry about the confusion! And I definitely know that I need coffee with a long day!

The song is one of my favorites! It's from LOTR Soundtrack and I thought it fit perfectly. So much light and dark all based on one war. Thank you so much for the lovely review! (:


 Report Review

Review #2, by Faith100z Draco Malfoy

6th February 2013:
Hi there! I'm here from the forums with your review :) Also, sorry for the delay. It turned out I had more homework than I originally thought.

Normally I wouldn't read such a Draco-centric fic but I really enjoyed this! You described his epiphany (I guess that's what you would call it?) so well. How he slowly realized he could try and change his values a little and do what was right.

I especially loved how you stayed true to a lot of his core personality traits. For example, you get the sense that he will still always save his own neck first. ("Between Father, Mother, and I, it was an unspoken consensus that by this point of the War, the only importance was our safety.")

You also get a feeling that he's still arrogant and a little proud but he realizes killing people isn't the answer and that he owes Harry a debt since he saved his life.

Good job, I really enjoyed this piece! :)

- Faith

Author's Response: I'm glad that you liked it!
Yeah, I normally wouldn't write a Draco-centered fic either, but this was the best opportunity, if that made any sense. Anyways, I'm glad that you can see Draco is still himself because that is the one thing that irks me: when Draco in Next Generation of Post-Hogwarts acts completely OOC xD

Thank you so much for this review! (:


 Report Review

Review #3, by Timechild Draco Malfoy

17th September 2012:
Nice job.

I could see Draco thinking this way.

Good work.

Author's Response: thank you so much! (:

 Report Review

Review #4, by kalkay Draco Malfoy

11th September 2012:
I loved this. Loved. This. Story.

I really liked how you brought in the idea of his values and how he reevaluates them. I like the idea of him making a promise to himself to change. It reminded me of the quote 'Be the change you want to be in the world' which is acclaimed to Gandhi. I can see how this built up over the years and I really like that you reference previous events.

This reminded me of the song 'Man in the Mirror' and the scene where Draco is in the bathroom...looking...in the mirror... anyways!

I really loved the look into his mind and how you did everything! I think that this is the perfect ending for this particular idea because values are not something that you can fix over night but something that you can decide to adjust.

Great insight. Great story. Brilliantly written! Loved it!

Author's Response: im so glad that you liked this!
that quote by Gandhi certainly fits Draco because he has to become the change.
hm i've never heard of that song but I'll have to check it out!
I think so too! The reason why I sympathized with Draco so much after HBP is because I feel like he gradually goes through this change and certainly not over night because in HBP we can see that he still isn't a great person. but then by the time that the war is over, we know that Draco has become a far better person.

thanks so much! i'm so glad you like it! :D



 Report Review

Review #5, by TyrannicFeenix Draco Malfoy

11th September 2012:
A very good fic, I really enjoyed it and a great perspective on Draco. This is kind of always how I thought his mind was working, though I'd always wondered why it had taken him so long to come around to the correct mindset, but you manage to portray it very well.

There were a few errors I noticed that I thought I'd point out for you:

"I hadn't mean for it to come to this" (meant)
"standing there in the sidelines" (think this should be on instead of in but that is just my opinion)
"sitting in my classes and I'd listen to her" (listened)
"if I could find a way to make fix it." maybe take out the make

Otherwise, all great work. I really loved it.

TyrannicFeenix

Author's Response: oohhh thanks so much for pointing out the mistakes!
and I'm so glad that you liked it! I always thought that an insight to Draco's mind would be interesting. Thanks so much for reading and reviewing! (:


 Report Review

Review #6, by Moondanser83 Draco Malfoy

11th September 2012:
I swear we are sharing a brain cell!
This is exactly what I pictured Draco thinking during this scene. His internal strugle between what he had been taught and what he knew in his heart was right... perfect. It actually lines up nearly perfectly with my own new Draco oneshot Final Bloom!
There were a few tense errors, but nothing a quick beta or reread won't take care of.
Wonderful job!
Keep up the great work!!

~Moon~

Author's Response: it looks like great minds think alike! Loll
and thanks for pointing out the mistakes!
im going back to correct them now hehe
thanks so much! thanks for reading and reviewing!


 Report Review
If this is your story and you wish to respond to reviews, please login