4 Reviews Found

Review #1, by MrsJaydeMalfoy One

16th December 2014:
Wow, this certainly brings back memories (of that House Cup, I mean)!

I love the way you incorporated the dragon, without making Susan a Dragon Keeper. A lot of people (myself included), decided to make her a Dragon Keeper, so it was nice and refreshing to see something different here!

I loved the mentions of Hagrid and his encouragement, and the appearances from Charlie and the other Dragon Keepers.

I think my favorite part was where you described the process of someone's friends convincing them to try a new flavor of ice cream... that was sooo realistic and easy to relate to, and described so well... amazing!

 Report Review

Review #2, by LadyL8 One

17th January 2014:
Hi Again, Tawi!

This was your story for The House Cup? It must've been my first HC then, cause I remember reading it. And I loved it then, and I love it now.

I think Susan's an interesting character, because your see very little of her in HP books. And that makes her almost an OC, because you have a lot of freedom when writing her.

But I loved your Susan. I loved that the story was about facing your fears, which in this case was dragons. I remember reading those prompt the first time, and thinking that it would be impossible to get many of them into the same story. But I guess you just proved me wrong, You got a lot of them into your story. And I didn't immediately recognize any of them as prompts, because they fit so well into your story. So well done.

I also loved your characterization. I think that she's very unconfident in the beginning, and that's also how I imagine her to be. But then she ends up facing her fears, and I also think that's very believable. And I loved Charlie's and Hagrid's help, especially the latter's advice,

Good work. Loved it!

- Lotte

 Report Review

Review #3, by maskedmuggle One

20th July 2012:
Hey! Aw this was a really sweet story and I loved seeing Susan shine here. She's such a minor character I've never read a story about her until the house cup, so it's great to see what everyone's been doing with her. I really liked her characterisation here - she was a bit unconfident in herself, but I absolutely adored Hagrid's advice to her and Charlie's help.

The plot itself is lovely - a nice idea to have Susan collect blood and face the dragon. I was surprised to see her wand get broken so that was a nice twist to the story I definitely wasn't expecting! Nicely written story - the prompts were used so well too - they fit in really well :)

- Charlotte

Author's Response: Thank you so much Charlotte! Really made me happy to see a review! :) Have a nice day!

Thanks again!


 Report Review

Review #4, by Sakurasou One

18th July 2012:
I love Susan in this. I think you characterised her really well and particularly I like her courage and her strength in facing the Herbridean Black! It was nice that you added a little bit of Hagrid to the story, its nice to see him as a friend to other students than just the trio :D

Your description is superb, especially the beginning where you describe her fear and the closeness of the dragon.

You really made me feel for Susan, I was totally cheering her on at the end when she finally faced her fear and approached the dragon.

Great oneshot, I really liked it :D

Author's Response: Oh my! I didn't think I'd ever get a review on this! Thank you so much Sakura, really nice of you :)

 Report Review
If this is your story and you wish to respond to reviews, please login