Reading Reviews for Reasons Why Not
4 Reviews Found

Review #1, by Infinityx Reasons Why Not

22nd January 2014:
Hey there! I'm here for the BvB review battle.

You've written this story wonderfully. It's so lighthearted and full of humor, and every line kept me smiling. I love the way you've portrayed Lily here. She's so different in character to the other stories I've read with her in them, and it was very refreshing to see her in such a way. I think it's great that she's in Ravenclaw. It certainly fits her character.

I love the interactions between Alice and Lily. They're so light, and the way the dialogues have been written also help to build their characters more.

I found the pace a little too fast in the beginning. Alice is talking to her father about detention, then Alice suddenly pulls Lily along the corridor, and just happens upon the ministry workers. It would have been nice to know a little more about why she wanted to have her detention rescheduled, and then what her intentions were when she pulled Lily along with her through the corridor. That part seemed a little bumpy to me.

You've written the part in which the potion is brewed, brilliantly. The instances when they both had their doubts, their trying not to get caught, the sense of urgency and Alice's skills at persuasion were so strongly depicted.

The last part was amazing. I couldn't stop laughing when I read all the professions of love. Lily's comment about the stars being balls of gas was a wonderful touch. It was exactly something she would say, and I love how you've shifted the view between the ministry workers and the two girls' reactions instead of just focusing on the workers.

I would want to claim responsibility as well if I was in their place! :D So I love how you've made Albus and Sophia enter the scene as well.

I think you've done a marvelous job at writing this. And of course, the ending line was perfect! :)

I'm so glad I read this! Keep writing!


Author's Response: Sorry for the very late review reply, Erin! I've read this review multiple times and found myself beaming every time, but I've forgotten to actually reply to it until now xD

This story has very recently been majorly edited, so I was glad to have an opinion on the new version of it :'D I'm glad you thought this was full of humour -- that was one of the main points of the challenge I entered this one-shot in, and I'm not entirely sure of myself when I write humour, so thank you muchly for your assurances. I'm not even going to deny it, Ravenclaw!Lily was my favourite part of this story. I've never seen her in Ravenclaw before but I loved the idea and I'm unbelievably pleased you liked her -- I'd write her again if I could!

I totally get what you mean about the too-fast pace at the start, and I'll definitely come back to this review when I revamp this story (again!). It honestly never occured to me to explain /why/ Alice wanted her detention rescheduled, haha, so thanks for pointing that out!

That was such a Lily line, I couldn't resist putting it in xD

Thank you so much for leaving such a sweet review on this! I am completely overwhelmed with how lovely this is, so thank you :D


 Report Review

Review #2, by Jchrissy Reasons Why Not

24th July 2012:
Oh my gosh this was such an amusing read. I love that you have Lily in Ravenclaw and that Alice is the one to instigate the bad behavior. It's such a different set of characterizations!

This is also the first story I've read that has Lily and Alice in the same year! But it makes perfect sense. I don't see why they couldn't be, and it's really fun to see how far the Longbottoms and Potters have come together.

Your writing is very smooth and I think you do a great job of not making obvious dialogue tags. You are creative when doing them, making the story feel more realistic.

I also like that you've made Lily good at potions, I think it's very possible it could have been a family trait and passed down from the grandmother she never had the chance to know.

I love the creativity to this, everything is so fresh and enthusiastic that it made it so much fun to read!!

Great one shot, and congratulations on the honorable mention!!!


Author's Response: Ah, hello there, my 80th reviewer! :) I can't believe you came and reviewed - you really shouldn't have, but I'm not complaining about it at all :p I think I ended up defying most of the Lily cliches in this story - being put in Ravenclaw, still cheeky but not as much as Alice and all that good stuff. I've seen various Alices, too, like you, and you're right, most of them are in Albus' year, but it's still really fun to write them.

Thanks a bunch for the review, Jami, and all those compliments! -squishes- This was so sweet, and a lovely 80th review for me :p See you around the forums, love!


 Report Review

Review #3, by luvinpadfoot Reasons Why Not

29th June 2012:
Hahaha! I was laughing through the whole story! This is a great portrayal of Lily and Alice! It's always how I imagined Lily, clever and mischievous. I think it's great that you made Neville's daughter one of the biggest troublemakers in the school.

And their love potion was a splendid idea! It made me laugh so hard! Great story!

Author's Response: Ohmygosh, thank you! This review was so sweet, and this Lily was always how I imagined her, too, and Alice is just amazing. If she was real, she'd definitely make an awesome friend :) I loved the love potion idea, too, and I'm really glad you liked this. Thanks for reviewing!

 Report Review

Review #4, by Live Life Large Reasons Why Not

20th June 2012:
Hey Linn! Sorry this took so long, I was on holiday and didn't want to write a three line, rushed review(;

First off, good job with incorporating the challenge! The quote you got was harder to work with than a lot of the others because it wasn't very specific, but you managed to pull it off brilliantly(:

This was also very interesting to read. The way you portrayed Lily was refreshing, because I'm so used to reading the fiery, off-the-handle, possibly psycho girl instead of the kind of careful, yet still daring character I read here. I quite liked it, and thought it was more realistic.

The last bit was hilarious. Though I do want to point out one thing: you didn't really specify that it was the Ministry workers who were swooning, and though I understood it, it could be potentially confusing.

One last tip: on the rare occasion, you'd include an action of one person's with the dialogue of another's in a way that was a bit confusing. For example,
"'C’mon, Soph, we’ve had enough ‘bonding time’ with my little sis and her friend.' Lily yelled after him.

'I’m not little!'"

You may want to think about revising it so that it can be clearer what Lily shouted. Maybe something like-

"'C’mon, Soph, we’ve had enough ‘bonding time’ with my little sis and her friend.'

Lily yelled after him, 'I’m not little!'"

Besides those two minor points, this was spot on(: It was entertaining, fit the challenge well, and there was plenty of dialogue, which I happen to enjoy quite a bit. By the way, I like the end note(;

Thanks for entering my challenge!
Live Life Large(:

Author's Response: Hi, Rylan! Nah, it's okay, I really don't mind - the extra long review /definitely/ makes up for it :) You're too sweet - I knew that I wanted Ravenclaws and Lily Potter, and that was pretty much it, so I'm glad it turned out well.

I adored Lily in this one - same as you, I'm always used to her being fiery and sassy, so writing her as being a little more careful with what she did, and still getting into trouble (because it's the Potter way :p) was a nice change for me.

Did I not mention that? Darn. I'll have to go back and fix that - still, I'm glad you understood it. I /do/ have that habit, don't I? Even I've noticed it popping up a lot, so someday soon, I might go back and fix this.

You gave me such a lovely, long review, so thanks - and I really enjoyed writing this for your challenge :) See you around at the forums!

- Linn

 Report Review
If this is your story and you wish to respond to reviews, please login