Reading Reviews for Someday When I Stop Loving You
  
4 Reviews Found

Review #1, by SANTA, THE MYSTERY BADGER! Someday When I Stop Loving You

22nd December 2013:
This was so sad! I think the ending was even more sad set up against the contrast of the previous section's relative happiness and hopefulness (when they're talking about the future, dancing, etc). It makes Marlenes death even more of a rude awakening.

You've got Sirius pegged perfectly here, I think that's very much how he would react. Poor guy :( Your descriptions of his anguish, and what's going on around him that he doesn't see, are really good.

I also liked the choice of other characters in this - the two other couples that are doomed as well. For some reason that seemed very fitting, in a sort of depressingly-ironic way.

This is really well done! Great work :) Also, happy winter solstice, since that's today.

Author's Response: Thanks for another awesome review, I love getting to hear your thoughts on the stories!

It means so much that you liked his reaction, I was pretty worried about writing him and doing his character justice, so I'm glad you liked it! Thanks again for being such a brilliant Secret Santa! :D


 Report Review

Review #2, by Secret Santa! Someday When I Stop Loving You

25th December 2012:
HO HO HO! MERRY CHRISTMAS!

It's your Hufflepuff Secret Santa!

This was really good! I think your characterised Sirius and Marlene really well!

You also portrayed the emotion really well, you really have a knack for writing emotionally moving pieces!

And for some really strange reason, I loved this line:

Slowly, the Dark Mark faded from the night sky, obliterated by the Order's spell.

It just gave me the heebjeebies, it was really powerful (in my mind).

Anyway, I really like this one-shot!

MERRY CHRISTMAS! :D

Author's Response: Hi there! Thanks so much for this review, it made my day!

I'm so glad you thought the emotion was all right, I was worried it sounded really cheesy and fluffy while I was writing.

Thanks again, you're super!


 Report Review

Review #3, by LillyRoseanne Someday When I Stop Loving You

10th June 2012:
I love it. I cried. My BF took the piss... Lol.
Seriously, I love it, despite your doubts about the end I really like it.
Thank you.

Author's Response: ohhh, im sorry i made you cry. haha but im glad you liked it, i really like that pairing. thank you so much for leaving a review, i love them!

 Report Review

Review #4, by charlottetrips Someday When I Stop Loving You

11th March 2012:
Hi! Lehulei from TGS with your requested review!

A couple of points of CC and then onto less specific points.
- JKR capitalizes “Muggle” in the book and so I think it’s a point to keep in here.
- “MacKinnon” is “McKinnon”, the first time you mention it.
- seize his heart in [it's] grip. - [its] – no apostrophe when you are making it a possessive noun (happens again later on)
- The moment he saw the dark mark floating eerily in the sky, presiding over the house Marlene called home. - The way this sentence starts out sounds like it should be part of another sentence. I know you meant to make it flow from the previous paragraph and it does, basically, but would be a little smoother with “It was” in the front as then it’ll sound more complete, you know? :)
- You did so well in the first section on description and really setting the mood and then kind of dropped it a little towards the end. I would just take another look to see what you could do to keep it in with those little things like a day’s-old newspaper which just makes the whole scene that much more real to me and not just so “set-up”.

Now, that I’m done with my critical reviewer’s duties…

OMG. The heart in this story is lovely. The way you started out the story, in such an innocuous fashion with Sirius and his Butterbeer and newspaper, it was a good set-up. The reflection of the night before gives us some idea of his regard for Marlene, the ease they have for each other and it flowed so well.

Then you ripped that away from me with this sudden loss. And then throw in an engagement ring as well! I liked how you described Sirius as going on autopilot and not even realizing what he was doing, just that he was feeling and suspended in disbelief at what was occurring. Describing how he didn’t realize all sorts of things happening around him really brought home to me how shocked he was by the whole thing. The Order obliterating the Dark Mark was a nice touch and then the end, aw man, poor Sirius.

I hope that was helpful!

xChar

Author's Response: First off, soo soo sorry about the lateness of this response, im a horrible person :s thanks for spotting those, ill remember them when i edit. same with the description. hahaha, im glad you liked it! thanks so much for the awesome review! totally helpful! again, sorry for the lateness!

 Report Review
If this is your story and you wish to respond to reviews, please login