I really enjoyed this fic - well done! I really liked your take on how Lupin and Tonks got together, it was really interesting! I like it when other people fill in the holes in the book so effectively. Well done again

Author's Response: Thanks, I'm glad you like it, it took me a long time to get this right, and I'm glad I took so much time over it as I'm quite proud of what I've come up with.

I'll tell you what though, I'm not looking forward to them dying in the last film (part 2)... I'm really not, having seen them get Dobby's death right, I'm preparing for major water works... :P
Thanks again :D
LR
xxx

 Report Review

This is really good! Great character development and flow. good luck on the challenge!

Author's Response: Thanks!

Glad you enjoyed it, I re-read al the Remus and Tonks bits in the books before starting in the hope of getting them right, and it looks like I did :D. Thanks again!

Much love
LillyRoseanne
xxx

 Report Review

It's acrules from the forums and... I love it. It may not be quite as 'bad' as some of the other romances (like you said on the forums) but it's very...

Well, for a start it is very well written and smooth, which I liked. Then it does seem, like you said, quite realistic and very Remus/tonkish, with the nice addition of them still arguing - and it all being about his flashback when he was dying... yes, I very much really liked it. *adds to favorites* :)

Author's Response: THANK YOU!!!

So glad you like it :D I really tried to work on my transitions with this one (they tend to be a bit sticky sometimes :D)

I'm glad I managed realistic without being too over the top, It's far too easy to slip into the habit(!). My main point I suppose was to cut out the 'sunshine and flowers' rubbish, because they were never about that, they were about fighting for love, and trying to live life as best they could despite it.

So thank you again, for an amazing challenge, it really was a challenge. Glad you liked the result :D

Much love
LillyRoseanne
xxx

 Report Review