{reviewid: 2503484, reviewer: 'Phillip'}
5th April 2011:
Are you still writing this story?
Report Review |
{reviewid: 2460750, reviewer: 'I%20LOVE%20HP'}
| Review #2, by I LOVE HP | Bill |
6th January 2011:
So funny and cute and aw bill can find a flaw with the savior of the world :) Luv it !
Report Review |
{reviewid: 2347152, reviewer: 'Ringo%20Beeblebrox'}
| Review #3, by Ringo Beeblebrox | Charlie |
14th May 2010:
I did not mean to post the review two times. The first time I tried to post it, there seemed to be network problems. I was instructed to resend the review. However, the first attempt was apparently successful.
Author's Response: its all good thanks for the advice.
Report Review |
{reviewid: 2347132, reviewer: 'Ringo%20Beeblebrox'}
| Review #4, by Ringo Beeblebrox | Charlie |
14th May 2010:
My initial reaction was to state you need to get a beta reader, but a beta reader should be used to give a story polish, to catch the odd mistakes (such as typos and changing tenses.) A beta reader should not be used to give the writer a crash course is fundamental grammar and punctuation. If this was to be graded, the plot would be a B or higher, but the writing would be an F or D.
You have run-on sentences. You writing questions but rarely use question marks. You capitalization is inconsistent (such as ALL personal nouns and the first word of a sentence). From all evidence, you didn't bother with the very basic concept of using a spell check. All of this is just off the top of my head. It got to the point that it was painful to read.
Report Review |
{reviewid: 2347131, reviewer: 'Ringo%20Beeblebrox'}
| Review #5, by Ringo Beeblebrox | Charlie |
14th May 2010:
My initial reaction was to state you need to get a beta reader, but a beta reader should be used to give a story polish, to catch the odd mistakes (such as typos and changing tenses.) A beta reader should not be used to give the writer a crash course is fundamental grammar and punctuation. If this was to be graded, the plot would be a B or higher, but the writing would be an F or D.
You have run-on sentences. You writing questions but rarely use question marks. You capitalization is inconsistent (such as ALL personal nouns and the first word of a sentence). From all evidence, you didn't bother with the very basic concept of using a spell check. All of this is just off the top of my head. It got to the point that it was painful to read.
Report Review |
{reviewid: 2347007, reviewer: 'aussieginny'}
14th May 2010:
You really need to do a spell and grammer check and read over ur chapters. i reakon they would be good if u did that but i just found this really frustrating 2 read because of all the typos
Report Review |
{reviewid: 2346701, reviewer: 'Lunas_Baby'}
13th May 2010:
I'm loving! Must read the next now! xD
Report Review |
{reviewid: 2340675, reviewer: 'Manwe%20Valarian'}
1st May 2010:
Good Chapter, I was wondering how you would give Freds POV.
Report Review |
{reviewid: 2340522, reviewer: 'dshadel'}
30th April 2010:
Good chapter I like the 3rd person better. can't wait for the next one.
Report Review |
{reviewid: 2340291, reviewer: 'Miss%20Weasely'}
30th April 2010:
This was wonderful. I read all three chapters in one go and I loved them. Some errors here and there, but over all its a wonderful story.
Good luck.
Report Review |
{reviewid: 2340181, reviewer: 'harryronhermione'}
| Review #11, by harryronhermione | Fred |
29th April 2010:
Your good at both first and third person. I think you'd be a great author. I liked it a lot and can't wait for the next chapter!
Report Review |
{reviewid: 2335622, reviewer: 'Husain'}
| Review #12, by Husain | Bill |
20th April 2010:
That was ingenious
Really it is...
Author's Response: Thanks i never had a sister and always wanted to voice how i would feel about a sister of mine having a boyfriend.
Report Review |
{reviewid: 2335315, reviewer: 'Mrs%20HJ%20Potter'}
19th April 2010:
This was such wonderful chapter. I think Bill's bet was fantastic, I would love to have seen the payback from Fleur.
Author's Response: I was planning on adding it but it would have extended the chapter way too far plus I dont think fleur would have collected on the bet she would have just played with him.
Report Review |
{reviewid: 2335196, reviewer: 'dshadel'}
19th April 2010:
Another good chapter, looking forward to the next one
Report Review |
{reviewid: 2334608, reviewer: 'harryronhermione'}
| Review #15, by harryronhermione | Bill |
18th April 2010:
It was good! I thought their reactions were really authentic Can't wait to see what Charlie has to say.
Update soon!!
Report Review |
{reviewid: 2334443, reviewer: 'dshadel'}
18th April 2010:
Good first chapter, looking forward to the next
Report Review |
{reviewid: 2332979, reviewer: 'harryronhermione'}
| Review #17, by harryronhermione | Ron |
15th April 2010:
Hey really cool story idea! I liked this, I can't wait to see who is up next...keep writing!
Report Review |