{reviewid: 2757046, reviewer: 'pottercrazy17'}
7th December 2012:
This chapter was really nice :) I just wish it was longer though. I'm kinda shocked at the thought that Godric and Rowena might have had a relationship. But at the same time, it seems really possible. But when I read the books, I've only ever seen the four founders as best friends with complex relationships. Still a good chapter though. :)
Report Review |
{reviewid: 2757042, reviewer: 'pottercrazy17'}
7th December 2012:
It's a great and very possible beginning of Salazar Slytherin's story and his hatred for muggles. It's a nice start and I can tell that it's gonna be good. Keep writing :)
Report Review |
{reviewid: 2738982, reviewer: 'Rettopyrrah'}
10th September 2012:
oh please give us more :3 i feel this could really go somewhere. genuinely
Report Review |
{reviewid: 2738975, reviewer: 'Rettopyrrah'}
10th September 2012:
ohgod this is too good. you rarely find a really good founders fic, but i think i have.
Report Review |
{reviewid: 2738973, reviewer: 'Rettopyrrah'}
10th September 2012:
ugh, founders is so under-appreciated. i love how you've got this background for why salazar hates muggles so much.
Report Review |
{reviewid: 2736283, reviewer: 'InfinitePottah'}
31st August 2012:
This is great! I've always wondered why some wizards - *cough* Slytherins! *cough* - hated the Muggles so much, and this all makes perfect sense! Great work :D
Report Review |
{reviewid: 2733991, reviewer: 'Jtorres'}
23rd August 2012:
Great story, I hope you update soon
Report Review |
{reviewid: 2713055, reviewer: 'Keikokeiko999'}
26th June 2012:
Please please please update! So far, this is a really good story. I loved delicate and still delicate, and this is just as good. Don't stop!
Report Review |
{reviewid: 2709625, reviewer: 'NightCrimson'}
17th June 2012:
I don't usually read Founders of Hogwarts..but this is nice:)
It is believable and pretty good..
Please update!
Report Review |
{reviewid: 2701101, reviewer: 'zazzy'}
| Review #10, by zazzy | Burnt |
25th May 2012:
i love your stories...they soo imaginative and addictive..ive got an exam tomorrow but cant stop reading...
Report Review |
{reviewid: 2693211, reviewer: 'Shayor'}
4th May 2012:
Love it! It's interesting to see the many different takes to the Founders Era! Well written and descriptive!
Report Review |
{reviewid: 2671597, reviewer: 'Potterblotter'}
12th March 2012:
So... guna need you to continue with this brilliant story. Delicate and Still Delicate were diamonds, this is gold. Please dont stop.
Report Review |
{reviewid: 2664015, reviewer: 'RosettaSmurf'}
23rd February 2012:
Please, please keep this one going!
Report Review |
{reviewid: 2655460, reviewer: 'LeonNnyl'}
7th February 2012:
great chapter, please keep writing :)
Report Review |
{reviewid: 2646954, reviewer: 'Amy%20McEvoy%20Roantree'}
21st January 2012:
That was a good chapter i cant wait to see how the story plays out. Will there be a next chapter and if so when?
Report Review |
{reviewid: 2646945, reviewer: 'Amy%20McEvoy%20Roantree'}
| Review #16, by Amy McEvoy Roantree | Burnt |
21st January 2012:
I love the idea of writing a founders story i always wanted to know more about them! Its so cool actually getting to here where the term 'mudblood' came from and why the slytherins are against muggles. Amy x
Report Review |
{reviewid: 2635776, reviewer: 'Aley'}
29th December 2011:
Sooo god! I demand more!
Report Review |
{reviewid: 2635113, reviewer: 'Hannah%20Seekings'}
28th December 2011:
its amazing! i really love it! do more soon! and the still delicate one too, its quite sad but every time i log on i check to see if you've written anymore chapters, my heart always sinks a bit when you haven't and leaps when you have! sad isn't it :P anyway, you are so talented it is unbelieveable! you should do a story about house elves. anyway thankyou for writing these strories! lots of love x
Report Review |
{reviewid: 2630900, reviewer: 'Rosie_xx'}
19th December 2011:
Keep up the good work, I can't wait for another chapter, if there is one! It's so interesting to see someone do a fan fiction from before Harry, Ron and Hermionie were even alive, before Hogwarts even!
Report Review |
{reviewid: 2630896, reviewer: 'ryan%20klodowski'}
19th December 2011:
you really need to write more for this story you are an amazing author.
Report Review |
{reviewid: 2614079, reviewer: 'MoTown'}
10th November 2011:
Solid follow-up to chapter 1 and, as usual, great writing. The story thus far is well-paced and very engaging. I'm interested in knowing how young Salazar got along on his own for the last six years, especially without a wand. I suspect to survive he had to associate himself in some manner with muggles and their bizarre idiosyncrasies, further fueling his hatred (as if the burning of his mother wasn't enough). This could be a short story in itself.
Nice work! I look forward to reading the next installment.
Report Review |
{reviewid: 2614071, reviewer: 'MoTown'}
10th November 2011:
I guess this answers my question (in a different review) wether any of your stories are written in the third person. As a history nut, I love your angle with this story. I like the way you handled Mildred's inability to use magic to extract her and Salazar from the sticky siutation (or shoud I say "Fiery" situation) by the misplacing of her wand.
I think it is safe to assume that Mildred was not an especially gifted witch, as she clearly did not believe she would be able to Disapparate (using Side-Along Apparition to bring her son along) without the use of her wand. Then again, it's quite possible that her emotional state at the time (fear for her life and that of her child) inhibited her ability to use the magic at all, especially without aid of her wand. It might have been interesting to add a brief scene of Mildred trying to desperately escape through Disapparition only to find that she is unable to do so. At that point, she then becomes resolute to her only reality--sacrificing herself to save her precious son.
Great start to what I think will be a very interesting story. Now off to Chapter 2...
Report Review |
{reviewid: 2612437, reviewer: 'Harrybookworm148'}
6th November 2011:
Update please!!! I'm a HUGE fan of your Delicate stories, and I was just on your author page and saw this story, and it sounds really good for what I've read of it already!!!
Report Review |
{reviewid: 2610601, reviewer: 'boo_to_you_too'}
1st November 2011:
Great story! So is Still delicate, keep writing, your really talented!
Report Review |
{reviewid: 2603579, reviewer: 'Amy'}
17th October 2011:
Hello!
I just wanted to let you know that you are my favourite writer on this website, and that you may have even inspired me to write my own fanfiction(someday). I have read Delicate and Still Delicate(eagerly awaiting the next chapter by the way!) and I was drawn in by both story lines, you really have great ideas and are very skilled at portraying your characters. I literally couldn't stop reading them! I was up till one or two in the morning for many nights in a row.
Anyway, I realise this is meant to be reviewing Duplicity, not Delicate, so I will get on with it.
I'm really enjoying this story so far, I had never really thought about the relationships between the founders of Hogwarts and so I was sucked into another one of your fanfics by your fantastic ideas! I think the idea of tension between the muggle and magical communities caused by witch burnings makes a lot of sense and works really well within the world of Harry Potter. I can't wait to read more :)
Report Review |