Reading Reviews for Atop Notting Hill
1 Reviews Found

Review #1, by stoirmeacha Anyone Else But You

20th October 2008:
I loved the beginning of this. Scratch that, I loved all of it, but I loved the way the beginning made me want to read more, as I wanted to know why. I thought the dialogue was really good, and generally, I felt as though the characters were living and breathing beside me on that hill. I loved the balance between his own thoughts and the action between them on the hill. His thought process was very realistic, and I thought your choice of words was really good.

It was really nice to read a one-shot about something not pivotal, which is unusual, and it was very calming and nice-to-read, if that makes sense. I loved the song lyrics too, and the way they were used.

There were just a couple of things though:
- at times there were words in the dialogue (eg. somewhat, Mother) that seemed a touch too formal, but other than that, it was really good, and built up the relationship between the characters well.
- I felt there was a bit of a leap at just one point with the point after the "You looked asleep", because my mind didn't automatically jump to that reaction, although I can understand how Ann did, but I wouldn't have thought Ted would have. This could just be me, of course.

Overall, I thought it was really good, and I loved reading it. 9.5/10

Author's Response: Thank you so much; I'm so glad you enjoyed it; and thank you so much for the compliments!

Hm... you have a point about the word choice, but I can't give you a satisfactory answer (I haven't read this since I wrote it, and honestly I don't think I can bring myself to do it XD) except that I do think there can be people who talk like that. Words like 'somewhat', I use when I talk all the time. As for Mother... it's probably just the kind of relationship you have with your mother. I use the formal word often when I talk to my mother (not in English though), but hey, to each his own.

As for the leap -- again, I haven't read it for ages, so I'll take your word for it. It doesn't seem unlikely that I made an illogical leap, I do it all the time, and I'm grateful for you having pointed it out. Thank you so much!

 Report Review
If this is your story and you wish to respond to reviews, please login