Reading Reviews for Eternal Bonds of the Heart
5 Reviews Found

Review #1, by lunylovegoodlover Petunia's Promise

14th March 2010:
This is heartbreaking! Poor Petunia...I wish she had just come to her senses a little earlier, and had never married Vernon. I love the ending of this. It's perfect.


 Report Review

Review #2, by rachm34 Petunia's Promise

8th December 2008:
wow... wow.. i took your advice and listened to this with the song in the backround and eventually wound up in tears. This is just really beautifullly written and completely emotional. I'm not even sure what to say about this. I loved this perspective coming from petunia. it shows that she understood what happened. You did a really good job with this. I have no cc

Author's Response: Thanks Rachel, I'm glad you liked it.


 Report Review

Review #3, by Weasleys Forever Petunia's Promise

4th May 2008:
Lovely. Petunia did love Lily and care for Harry in your story. How sad to lose someone and not have a chance to settle old quarrels and resentments. I am glad Lily's ghost or whatever gave Petunia forgiveness.

Keep writing.

Author's Response: Exactly, that's why one should never put things off! I'm glad you liked it and thanks for reviewing!

Huggles, Lily

 Report Review

Review #4, by C D johnson Petunia's Promise

3rd May 2008:
Hello Lily,

I thought this was a fantastic song fic! I was actually listening to the song at the time I was reading it (like you suggested) I discovered that the song really does fit this fic!

One of my most favourite parts in this fic was the line, “I always knew you didn’t hate me Tuney! Just take good care of my son and remember you’ll be in my heart, always.” Its just as if Lily has been with Petunia in spirit ever since the night she died on Halloween!

This fic also shows somthing else about Petunia, it shows that she is not as mean as JKR makes her out to be!

Well done Lilly, another great fic from you I give you a 10/10!

Keep in touch via e - mail! I'd like to know what you have planned next in fan fiction

Yours Magically,

Author's Response: Thanks Craig, I'm glad you enjoyed it, since this was my first songfic and I was definitely not confident it would turn out well! Rose sent me a mail saying you both reached an agreement about the banner for this story and that you'll make it together.
I'm glad you've worked out your confusion and disagreements because this time it was over my banner, which I felt really bad about. lol, anyways all's well now and I'm glad all conflicts are resolved!

Hugs, Lils

 Report Review

Review #5, by stunning_incubus Petunia's Promise

3rd May 2008:
that was interesting.

ill probably see Petunia in a better light from now on=)

Author's Response: Thanks, its good to know I achieved my goal of making her likable. Honestly, even before DH I'd always felt it must be a façade, those feelings she portrayed towards Lily are a normal part of growing up but as I say in the story its unlikely that she really hated her!

Hugs, Lily

 Report Review
If this is your story and you wish to respond to reviews, please login