Reading Reviews for The Fallen Angel
17 Reviews Found

Review #1, by sinwillys822 The Fallen Angel

15th January 2011:
i very much enjoyed the story. 10's all around!

Author's Response: Wow, thank you, dear sinwillys822!

 Report Review

Review #2, by Vermouth The Fallen Angel

13th June 2010:
Oh ... my ... God this is so moving. I cried at the end! How did you come up with a story like this?

If only it was a little longer... (Do I sound greedy?)

It's post-DH, isn't it? I'm new here, and I'm starting on a story of my own, also post-DH. If you're familiar with "Snapegirl"'s stories, you would see Severus finding solace in soulmates like Amelia Amarotti, fromk a very early time in his life, but in my story, Severus will find love after been bitten by that snake, so his heart would be much harder for that special lady to pry open ...

In a few days the first chapter will be validated and posted. Please check it out!


Author's Response: Dear Vermouth, thank you very much for your review! I'll check out your story, indeed! wings

 Report Review

Review #3, by David The Fallen Angel

17th April 2010:
Hi there!
Sometimes it's just so hard to find something on this site that's not 100% poppycock, I consider you as one of my favorite authors here (though I'd really like to see the next chapter of Venomous candy!) and I'll try to find time to read your other stories.
Now to the story...
You really kept to your word, the dialogues between Lily and Severus are really intelligent and not a single syllable is boring!

However... first, may I ask if you can make adjustments to already-posted stories? If so, then you can consider my little suggestion:

Are you familiar with stories that contain LONG quotations and dialogue, like Sherlock Holmes? Then you'd notice that when a person's words are divided into paragraphs, they go like this:


"ghr, tefhtr, tefhgt.

"htjydjhdtyet, 'fghgrs?' trhshtrs, 'fehsgdhntr.' aehdfg.

"gsrhrgshtetewh, ehthgeeaea; shettheeth.


Pay no attention to the letters themselves, I'm just using them to make up space. What I'm trying to tell you is that you should begin one's speech with a single quotation mark at the beginning of 1st paragraph, then start a new paragraph with a single quotation mark in the beginning, and so on, until you reach the speech's end, with quotation marks at both the beginning and end of said final paragraph. That way, you see, readers could make sure that they're reading a complete part of a character's words and not get confused trying to figure out whether its part of a quotation or not.

So if you can, would you be so kind as to add some necessary quotation marks? Then your story would really be perfect!

Author's Response: Hi David!

Wow, thank you very much! I really rarely get such constructive reviews, and now I'm truly grateful.
Of course I can change my already posted chapters, why not?
So far, I have to admit, I was not familiar with this kind of quotation, but I'm a keen learner. :) I think I have some Sherlock e-books somewhere on my hard drive, so I'll try to correct my story according to what you've said.
As you might know, I'm not a native speaker, so I greatly rely on suggestions made by my readers!
Thank you, David! Thank you very much and I hope to see you again!


 Report Review

Review #4, by snapeangel The Fallen Angel

16th June 2009:
lovely story, made me cry by the end

Author's Response: OMG! That\\\'s so nice to hear! Thank you!

 Report Review

Review #5, by looneyleeleelovegood The Fallen Angel

29th November 2008:
That was a very beautiful story.

And completely unlike anything I have ever read before. I'm not really sure why but it really reminded me of the Cathy/Heathcliff/Young Cathy conflict in Emily Bronte's 'Wuthering Hieghts'.

Lily was perfectly characterised, that was how I had imagined her, and the language was very intellegent and moving.

Well done! This is definatly going to be added as a favourite!

Author's Response: OMG! What can I say? It was a beautiful review! Thank you dear Leelee! This story came quite suddenly, because I felt bitter and shaken after the seventh book; I just had to vent these feelings. This story haven't received many reviews, though I find it one of the deepest of my stories. Thank you for discovering and understanding its depth! Thank you! That is the most flattering thing an author can receive! Thank you! Love, wings

ps: waiting for the rest of your SS/HG story!

 Report Review

Review #6, by Cfm887 The Fallen Angel

26th February 2008:
Wow. That was intense. I can't think of what else to say. Beautiful and moving. Thank you

Author's Response: Hi Cfm887,

I'm glad that the story was able to express the deep emotions behind the words. It was hard to write because of all the emotions that had whirled in my mind.
Thanks for appreciating it! Thanks for being such a faithful reader! wings

 Report Review

Review #7, by GREENTIGEREYES The Fallen Angel

2nd January 2008:
i really like this fic. it's dark and Lily is so different then how most people write her. does Lily love Severus enstead of James? 20/10

Author's Response: Hello GREENTIGEREYES,
thanks for your review! Lily loves them both, I think. It's a difficult question, you know, and perhaps not even Lily could tell whom she loves better. I believe she regrets treating Snape the way she treated. Thanks a lot, wings

 Report Review

Review #8, by miss_remus The Fallen Angel

4th December 2007:
Oh this was just tragic, and like nothing else I've ever read before. I like your characterization of Lily and how she isn't perfect. I liked how for a change, she had to apologize to Severus instead of the other way around; it's a breath of fresh air.

There's nothing more that I can say about this, but it was beautiful and very well written (of course) and I thinkl you're such an amazing writer!!

Author's Response: Miss Remus, thank you so much. You can't imagine how much your words mean to a writer! Thank you very much! wings

 Report Review

Review #9, by ShantiSnape The Fallen Angel

4th December 2007:
I like it a lot, especially Lily admitting she hurt him, in a way she did push him closer to the Dark Arts. I liked the conversations, especially Sev's and I loved this line: "You were a fallen angel, Severus, and you returned at last


Author's Response: Hi Shanti, I'm glad you liked this! I have read your Broken Angel on the other site, but I couldn't leave a review, I have to register first. I will so wait for it. :) wings

 Report Review

Review #10, by strangegirl6125 The Fallen Angel

13th October 2007:
SOO long! lol, very good.

Author's Response: Thanks a LOT! wings

 Report Review

Review #11, by bec The Fallen Angel

29th September 2007:
Beautiful : } loved it, well done!!! Rating = 10 : }

Author's Response: Thanks Bec! I'm soooo glad you liked it. Thanks for reviewing! wings

 Report Review

Review #12, by Severus my hero The Fallen Angel

28th September 2007:
Oh my goodness, it was absolutely fabulous. I have to say it must have taken some very hard work to write such a masterpiece and let me tell you dear it worked! It absolutely worked, I am adding this to the list of my favorite stories as it deserves to be. :o I am utterly fascinated by it. Thumbs up.

Author's Response: Wow! I think all writers are praying for such encouraging reviews. Yes, it was hard work and I had many doubts whether the readers would accept a story, where the characters were shown in a drastically psychological way. Altough it's longer than 5000 words, I felt it was still too short to describe everything that was hidden in these two characters. But then I realized that maybe less is really more. :) I think most writers face this problem sooner or later. So, thank you very much for your lovely review, you can't imagine how much it means to me. Thanks, wings

 Report Review

Review #13, by FreakOut13 The Fallen Angel

21st September 2007:
It was a pleasure for me to beta such a wonderful piece. :)

Author's Response: Thanks! You helped me a lot, not only with grammar, but your positive opinion of my work! Wish everyone had a beta like you! wings

 Report Review

Review #14, by XxWoahthatswickedxX The Fallen Angel

14th September 2007:
I did enjoy this story...I have to admit, more than I ever thought I would!
I love the way your story fills in so many unfilled characterization and plot gaps. I was never bored with the characters dialouge, I was actaully intrigued.

I can't find anything poor in this story, except for some of the formatting, but you've already mentioned in the beginning that you were aware of that.

So now I have to thank you for opening my eyes to a story I probably would not have read on my own.

Thank you!

I'm XCentaur on HPFF!

Author's Response: Dear Centaur! I'm so glad you decided to read this story.
I love honest reviewers like you, it means so much to a writer to impress a reader, who isn'tm really interested in a story or a special ship.
In one word, dear Centaur, you made my day! Thanks! You're great!

 Report Review

Review #15, by bron The Fallen Angel

6th September 2007:

but i dont agree that snape hated harry. i think he just pretended to...

really well done

i like the different side of lily!

Author's Response: Well, thanks Bron! I wasn't sure readers would like Lily that way, but I'm glad you liked her! Well, as for Snape... do you think Snape just played the role of the irritated teacher? I don'T think so, but who knows. Maybe he hated Harry, maybe he didn't. I think he hated Harry because he made Lily's choice of James final and unquestionable. He was the proof of Snape's defeat. I think. Well, anyway, thanks for your review! wings

 Report Review

Review #16, by xxstaindrosesxx The Fallen Angel

2nd September 2007:
Awww! That was really good!

Author's Response: Thanks a lot for your review! wings

 Report Review

Review #17, by Diandra The Fallen Angel

2nd September 2007:
This was very well written and incredibly sad. The banner alone made me cry (I'm a Severus obsessive, even more so a Severus/Lily obsessive). I loved how they explained everything to each other and how, no matter what, Severus would never get what he wanted. Great job!


Author's Response: Dear Diandra!
I think the same way as you, that ship is the most moving part of the whole story. That'S why I wrote this story.
Thanks a lot for your review!

 Report Review
If this is your story and you wish to respond to reviews, please login