Reading Reviews for Concerning Hobbits
7 Reviews Found

Review #1, by FlufferNutter Concerning Hobbits...

17th August 2007:
Love Hobbits, Loved the story. Adorable (meaning charming and worthy of being adored.)

Author's Response: Aw thank you :)

 Report Review

Review #2, by Weasley twins rock Concerning Hobbits...

7th June 2007:
Yep you were right I think it is a bit out of character, although it is a very funny fic in a weird little way. I personally could not see James and Lily, I saw two original characters bickering over an old book, I did have a sneaky suspicion that it was them though, Lily I can imagine as a book-worm, but not to the extremes as you have written her!
Yeah it was quite good, fairly out of character but if it was completely in character, I think that it would take the charm of the fic away.

Author's Response: I didn't think Lily was that booky, of course, it all depends on your own idea of what Lily was like :D That's wahts so great about the Marauders; you're not so tied to canon personifications!

Thanks for the nice review; the fact that you thought it was good depite its oocness made me quite happy! I tried writing it as a ron-hermione (b/c hermione is quite booky, after all) but it just didn't work; Ron is not near as fun-loving as James! Thank you, once again, for the review!

 Report Review

Review #3, by NicerDraco2025 Concerning Hobbits...

19th March 2007:
Yes it is better than the original trilogy!

This seems more like a Lily/James than Hermione/Ron.

Good job with this, the title and concept pulled me in. My copy of Hobbit is battered like that one. Muggleborns bringing in recognizable things like that are always fun. Keep it up.

Author's Response: Yay, a lotr person who agrees with me; woot!

Glad it pulled you in and you thought it was a good lilja fic. I like muggleborn-wizard connections, too, for they are fun! Thank you for the review!

 Report Review

Review #4, by Dragonflame_05 Concerning Hobbits...

25th February 2007:
I love Lord of the Rings and Pern and James and Lilly and Padfoot. I don't know about King, never read any of his books. This was really funny by the way. I liked it. You know I'd go out witha guy if he bought be books.

Author's Response: King's okay, but can be really boring....and I'm glad you liked it! I thought it was a nice way for a guy to pick a girl up to (who doesnt love books?)

 Report Review

Review #5, by WilowTree Concerning Hobbits...

23rd February 2007:
This fan fic is super good! 10/10

Author's Response: Thank you!

 Report Review

Review #6, by green_eyed_flower Concerning Hobbits...

22nd February 2007:
hahahaha that was really cute and the stories used were really good too! and yeah it could be a Hermione fic but i liked it as James/Lily it worked for them and you still gave James an immature side without being a complete jerk good job!! i really liked this and think you should write more like it! 10/10 Lots of Love ~Lily

Author's Response: Hmm...more like it; I might try...I've always been a Neville fan, but James is fun to write for one-shots, just because he's immature (and no more a jerk than all us other teenage boys)

 Report Review

Review #7, by voldy_sucks88 Concerning Hobbits...

22nd February 2007:
hahah i liked it... new twist on an old concept!! two thumbs up!

Author's Response: I'm glad you liked it!

 Report Review
If this is your story and you wish to respond to reviews, please login