Reading Reviews for What Say You?
5 Reviews Found

Review #1, by Weasley twins rock A Fine Establishment

20th January 2007:
Cool! You have managed to conjure those characters and put them in word exactly as I see them in my minds eye! It was so elaborately written and the characterisation was perfect. I do hope that if you haven't yet, that you consider writing a founders novel, it would be such a thrill to read. I adore your writing style and I look forward to reading some of your other works.

Author's Response: Wow! Thank you! I worked very hard to develop their characters and show the contrast of each of their personalities and I'm so happy that you enjoyed it.

I hadn't even thought about writing a novel about the founders! I wouldn't know where to begin! I usually stick to one-shots because I have a very short attention span and I'm horrible at developing plots... But I'll definately think about it, it sounds interesting.

I really appreciate all of your compliments, thank you so much!

 Report Review

Review #2, by purplepygmypuff A Fine Establishment

19th January 2007:
I normally don't read founders stuff because for the most part I'm just not interested in that era, however, because it was you, Jess, of course I clicked! And I'm so glad that I did. This was a great portrayal of the founders- much different than the ones that I have read. I loved how you brought them out of character for what we typicall think of when we think of characteristics of students of a particular house: Godric's drunkeness and sloth- because Gryffindors give everything they have to a cause, even if they have to find it in the bottle; Rowena's snobbery when it comes to those who aren't the smartest- to be honest, I've always felt Terry Boot and the rest of them were quite stuck up, but maybe that's just because JKR doesn't ever really tell us much about them; Helga's ability to take charge of the conversation- this was a wonderful touch, because you don't see Hufflepuffs doing it enough, but I always felt like they could, if needed; and Salazar's cunning- normally painted by goody two shoes Gryffindors as a bad thing, but here used like it should be to get exactly what he wants.

Wonderful! The whole thing!


Author's Response: Thank you so much, Erin! I'm so glad you enjoyed it. I was very hesitant about it because I was trying to make it realistic and blah blah blah but... Thank you! I appreciate your comments so much!

 Report Review

Review #3, by Arun A Fine Establishment

18th January 2007:
Hey nice attempt at capturing the mood and environment of the founder foursome u plan any continuation?

Author's Response: Thanks, not at this point but I may come back to it later... I appreciate your review!

 Report Review

Review #4, by shel A Fine Establishment

18th January 2007:
A short, but good insight into the history of Hogwarts

Author's Response: Thanks :]

 Report Review

Review #5, by Fallstar A Fine Establishment

13th January 2007:
Oh Lord that drivel made me want to vomit. The best that can be said for it was that no canon was violated and no grammer rules broken.

Author's Response: Gee, that was helpful. Next time you might try some CONSTRUCTIVE criticism. Thanks.

 Report Review
If this is your story and you wish to respond to reviews, please login