{reviewid: 2480857, reviewer: 'jrg0715'}
15th February 2011:
I really enjoyed being pushed out of my comfort zone through your story. You did a great job of keeping the characters true to form but by putting them in a different scenario than we are used to, you gave us a whole new perspective. Very well done!
Report Review |
{reviewid: 2288831, reviewer: 'Saffiecat911'}
23rd January 2010:
WoW! Such a great story! I like how practically everyone died though I wish that Draco was actually good and not heartless like his father.
*throws a positive review at you*
Saffiecat911
Report Review |
{reviewid: 2251628, reviewer: 'LadyLikable'}
9th November 2009:
...Yikes. Yikes. Yikes. O.O
Report Review |
{reviewid: 2049350, reviewer: 'iamme14'}
4th February 2009:
this was a sad, but very good story. 10/10
Report Review |
{reviewid: 1708322, reviewer: 'Bears%20Kitty'}
12th November 2007:
i like the story but the chapters werent long enough and the story felt to rushed it really could have been a lot better than it was but it was better than anything i myself could have written
Report Review |
{reviewid: 1708254, reviewer: 'Bears%20Kitty'}
12th November 2007:
James was a Seeker not a Chaser
Report Review |
{reviewid: 1597199, reviewer: 'james%20and%20sirius%204%20eva'}
| Review #7, by james and sirius 4 eva | The Fall |
26th August 2007:
wow really good story, still can't get over the fact that harry was in slytherin and friends with draco malfoy. i wish harry and sirius had a better relationship though how unfair, seeing the only family you had that loved you die.
good job
Report Review |
{reviewid: 1596975, reviewer: 'James%20and%20sirius%204%20eva'}
25th August 2007:
ah how could you put harry in slytherin its not fair ahhh
Report Review |
{reviewid: 1535398, reviewer: 'Fallstar'}
26th July 2007:
Interesting, if a banal and tired premise.
Report Review |
{reviewid: 1433385, reviewer: 'asian'}
26th May 2007:
Awww that was a great story overall. I like how you decided to change what house Harry was put into. A totally original idea and an awesome story!
Report Review |
{reviewid: 1433379, reviewer: 'asian'}
26th May 2007:
No! Did you have to kill Sirius off so early?
Report Review |
{reviewid: 1433292, reviewer: 'asian'}
26th May 2007:
Well that was unexpected.
Report Review |
{reviewid: 1413251, reviewer: 'mrsmolly'}
11th May 2007:
this cannot be the end!
Report Review |
{reviewid: 1323233, reviewer: 'Lord%20Lugos'}
27th February 2007:
*faints* How could you kill them all? *faints again*
Report Review |
{reviewid: 1323227, reviewer: 'Lord%20Lugos'}
27th February 2007:
No! How could you? Not Sirius!
Report Review |
{reviewid: 1323214, reviewer: 'Lord%20Lugos'}
27th February 2007:
Oh, you're dragging this out so much it hurts! The tantilising effect makes me want to stop reading, though that's clearly impossible. Argh!
Report Review |
{reviewid: 1323195, reviewer: 'Lord%20Lugos'}
27th February 2007:
Uh oh. But I can guess that Ron is now possessed by Voldey, and will therefore die when he vacates. So sad. Good story.
Report Review |
{reviewid: 1323175, reviewer: 'Lord%20Lugos'}
27th February 2007:
This is so good, but it hurts. I think I need some of that bottled courage.
Report Review |
{reviewid: 1323164, reviewer: 'Lord%20Lugos'}
27th February 2007:
Oh bloody hell, the real manipulations begin. I expect Snape will be Slytherin enough to tell Harry the truth, all of it. I hope. Crap! I'm rooting for Snape? Oh dear.
Report Review |
{reviewid: 1323157, reviewer: 'Lord%20Lugos'}
27th February 2007:
Wow, this is good, but as an author and fan of Sirius Harry stories, I do hope they work it out.
Report Review |
{reviewid: 1323151, reviewer: 'Lord%20Lugos'}
27th February 2007:
Yep, two sides of the same coin, Ron and Draco. Although it does hurt to see Sirius losing his godson, and Harry losing a caring parental figure, all because of prejudice and arrogance.
Report Review |
{reviewid: 1323144, reviewer: 'Lord%20Lugos'}
27th February 2007:
Ah, warped minds think alike. Some similar elements in our stories, though, I expect it's only natural as there are 98,834,298,423,239 HP fanfic stories out there. But I admit, I'm pissed at myself. the 'a law unto itself' comment was truly brilliant, and I wished I had thought of it when I did my own Harry on the Slytherin quidditch team scene.
I am enjoying this, so I'm off for more.
Report Review |
{reviewid: 1323123, reviewer: 'Lord%20Lugos'}
27th February 2007:
It was fun, but now I'm really starting to hate Ron. He's acting as arrogant as Draco regarding Slytherins. You're the second author to make me realise that even in canon, Ron and Draco are two sides of the same coin.
Report Review |
{reviewid: 1323109, reviewer: 'Lord%20Lugos'}
27th February 2007:
Wow, this is fun. So much fun. Snivellus was so funny. And Draco is just such and arrogant prat. Oh what fun. Ooh, there's more. Heehee.
Report Review |
{reviewid: 1323099, reviewer: 'Lord%20Lugos'}
27th February 2007:
Oh my, that was brilliant. And you've actually inspired me, I need to write a flashback of sorts, as the Sirius in my story isn't as nutters about Harry being in Slytherin, and I've got a little speech for him as to why he isn't. Of course, he did goto Askaban, and that's part of it. Oh brilliant! Bravo! And off we go for more.
Report Review |