Reading Reviews for 5 years.
  
5 Reviews Found

Review #1, by Aashna Helping Rowena: The Feast

1st September 2009:
Hi Ravensdaughter
well, interestin enough chappie.. i liked d way Rachel is adjustin well despite bein seperate from her frnds. n hmm I cud see d subtle hints which u gave regardin Fred.. i guess dey wud compliment each other dat is if dey get together or anythin. Anyways, very good chappie n i sure wud like 2 read more.. hope u update soon of course after d que opens. Gr8 job on all of ur chappies so far!
-Aashna
PS: Would u please be kind enhough to comment on my new story in the form of a review of course. I would really like to know ur thoughts abt it. The story is called 'A Tryst With Destiny'
Thank You.

Author's Response: Thanks for the reveiws. I'll look at your story. Love the title.
Ravensdaughter


 Report Review

Review #2, by Aashna Helping Rowena: The Sorting Ceremony.

1st September 2009:
Hi Ravensdaughter
well, dat was quite a turn.. i was assumin dat Rachel wud definitely b in Gryffindor but definitely d Ravenclaw turn was very very out of d blue. I hope her relationship wid Hermioen as best frnds sustains despite bein in 2 diff. houses.. Nonetheless, Gud chappie! I luk fwd 2 d next.
-Aashna

Author's Response: Yeah I'll explain that when Rachel gets to her third year.
Ravensdaughter


 Report Review

Review #3, by Aashna Helping Rowena: I've met you before!

1st September 2009:
Hi Ravensdaughter
a lill short but another nice chappie.. i liked d way Fred and George helped Rachel n i cud see dat by Hermione's last line dat u r definitely makin a connection in synchronisation wid d events of d book.. very nice attempt indeed. Good job on dis n am on2 d next chappie!
-Aashna

Author's Response: Thanks. I'm trying to make this so it could of really happened and is just an different perspective on the original books to be honest. Thank you for the nice comments
Ravensdaughter


 Report Review

Review #4, by Aashna Helping Roweana: New school, new friends, new foes.

31st August 2009:
Hi Ravensdaughter
Hmm.. Racher is takin a lot after Harry.. as in u know confused abt d way n den askin 4 help from Mrs. Weasely. I liked d wa u r connectin d story from d books inspite of havin a new character.. d way Hermione went lookin 4 Trevor in d end definitely provided a nexus. So, overall, a good job!
-Aashna

Author's Response: Thanks for noting that. I'm trying to make her different. I'll see how it goes.
Ravensdaughter


 Report Review

Review #5, by Aashna Helping Rowena: Things start to Kick off!

31st August 2009:
Hi Ravensdaughter
good plot-line.. hmm.. a story solely abt friends is really intriguing.. The first chappie was nice.. i liked readin abt a new character- Rachel dat is. Sounded a bit like Harry u know proff. Mcgonagall comin n explanin thins n escortin her around. But, good one.. although, it was a lill short n umm a lil rushed up at some places. If u wud've described more, den, it wud've flared up even more better. Nonetheless, a gr8 job!
am on 2 d next.
-Aashna

Author's Response: Thanks for comenting. I'm probably going to edit this alot as a I go through the other chapters.
Ravensdaughter


 Report Review
If this is your story and you wish to respond to reviews, please login