Reading Reviews for Sitting on the Bookshelf
  
31 Reviews Found

Review #1, by wantingtobe What is this Feeling?

12th August 2006:
Good read

 Report Review

Review #2, by Kerryanah Black Surprise!

18th October 2005:
I thought the story started brillantly and i loved the poem and stuff. but i felt it got a bit out of control, you didn't bring across the transition from hat to human realistically (HP realistically). And i felt the characterisation of the hat was rather different from the one we see in the book or the film.

Author's Response: well we all have our own opinions. And as for him transitioning...the hat is a magical object that turns into a human..... you really can't say i didn't do it realistically because DUH...its not real! LMAO.

 Report Review

Review #3, by coffee What is this Feeling?

8th July 2005:
wow, wow, so adorable! cuuute! puppy love ^^ keep going!

Author's Response: uh....the story is done, that was the end.

 Report Review

Review #4, by pretty in pink Ollivander's

18th May 2005:
hmm... so he's getting a bit of romance... how sweet! and also slightly creepy considering he's a hat...

Author's Response: lol...yeah. i know i just had to be a bit strange...hey everyone needs love...even hats....i mean...he does actually have brains and a personality.

 Report Review

Review #5, by CandyCane Ollivander's

18th May 2005:
i wanna know wat's up with ginny! (ok, i just noticed how much i sounded like a spoiled brat. oh well, i wanna know wat's up with ginny!) cool chapter! cant wait for more!

Author's Response: lol....now you see how i felt reading your stories!!!! lol... dont worry all will be revealed...

 Report Review

Review #6, by CandyCane I dream of red

18th May 2005:
ok, i got a bit behind, but i'm reading ur new chapters eventually! heehee, he fancies Ginny! it's so funny! and kinda sweet. despite the age gap...

Author's Response: lol...well ever since he turned human he is supposedly a 7th year...and ginny being a 6th year its ok...technically he isn't even 1 year old....human that is...but of course as a hat he is idunno...ancient? lol....

 Report Review

Review #7, by coffee Ollivander's

17th May 2005:
cuuute!!

Author's Response: lol...thankx

 Report Review

Review #8, by Katielynn Ollivander's

17th May 2005:
interesting...Edward is clueless...merefolk..interesting..

Author's Response: it only gets more random...lol

 Report Review

Review #9, by Katielynn I dream of red

17th May 2005:
interesting...green hair? seriously!?! thats awesome....

Author's Response: :) yep green hair...had to have my fave color somewhere.

 Report Review

Review #10, by Katielynn Surprise!

17th May 2005:
this is good...the sorting hat..or Edward as he is now called is hilarious!

Author's Response: :)

 Report Review

Review #11, by Katielynn I'm Only Human

17th May 2005:
the sorting hat goes human...thats hilarious!

Author's Response: :)

 Report Review

Review #12, by Katielynn The Sorting Hat

17th May 2005:
that was hilarious!

Author's Response: :)

 Report Review

Review #13, by SecretiveDarkness The Sorting Hat

16th May 2005:
Very original and creative. I love it! Keep up the great work.

Author's Response: thanks. i should have chapter 6 up in a few days.

 Report Review

Review #14, by coffee I dream of red

16th May 2005:
romance blossoming, i'm sure of it.

Author's Response: lol...just wait until next chapter....my story is complete RANDOMNESS!!!! lol...

 Report Review

Review #15, by pretty in pink I dream of red

15th May 2005:
Hmm... do I detect some romance a-blossoming here?

Author's Response: lol.... hmmm....maybe....the other chapter is in limbo ......

 Report Review

Review #16, by coffee Surprise!

1st May 2005:
never stopping to amaze...martial arts? hmm...maybe he should be on the quidditch team

Author's Response: lol.... well if a hat sits on a bookshelf for all these years.....he's got to know some things right? lol....

 Report Review

Review #17, by CandyCane Surprise!

28th April 2005:
heehee "Dumbie"! luv it! cant wait for more!

Author's Response: lol...yeah i just needed to find a nickname for him and i was like hey wait a minute....sometimes he is a bit dimwitted for the smartest wizard around....lol....

 Report Review

Review #18, by pretty in pink Surprise!

28th April 2005:
hee hee! This is so good!

Author's Response: i love being crazy.

 Report Review

Review #19, by Weasley Freckles Surprise!

28th April 2005:
Haha, I like this story! It's so different and original! Sometimes a little confusing to follow, but very enjoyable nonetheless. I love the physical characteristics you gave "Edward," that's exactly how the sorting hat should look if it were human! This is very interesting indeed, please update soon! ^_^

Author's Response: Yes i know its hard to follow but i actually like it that way. Its sort of his pov but sometimes gets off track. Even though he's a smart hat he's sort of like star wars YODA. lol.

 Report Review

Review #20, by coffee I'm Only Human

27th April 2005:
this decision will be a hard one..but i'm sure you'll make the best choice. can't wait til some girl falls heads over heels (over hats) in love with him ^0^

Author's Response: lol.....it is hard to decide where to put him....i mean he was godric's hat but he possess so much smarts, but it was very sneaky of him to change from a hat to a human using poor hermione.....hmmmm....decisions decisions....

 Report Review

Review #21, by CandyCane I'm Only Human

26th April 2005:
cliffy! uve been reading too many of toni's chapters! cant wait to see wat happens next! so funny! totally original! running out of words! but u know it's great! :)

Author's Response: lol....i told you two that you give me PLOT BUNNIES!!!!!

 Report Review

Review #22, by pretty in pink I'm Only Human

26th April 2005:
I worry about you sometimes... but, that being said, that was great! It's so... different... So, have you got any ideas for you're next chapter? Now that he's human(ish), he can have all sorts of happy little adventures...

Author's Response: hmmm...well of course i was thinking i have to put him in a house....then he needs a interesting romantic encounter....will he get his own wand? etc....

 Report Review

Review #23, by Cutie01 I'm Only Human

26th April 2005:
Duh duh duh!!! Poor hat, he couldn't at least become a hot person? Ah well!

Author's Response: lol in his own way he is cute....he just has green hair and wild cat eyes and a bit more softer skin then us lol

 Report Review

Review #24, by Cutie01 The Sorting Hat

26th April 2005:
Lol he's free!! This is so cute, good job!

Author's Response: lol yea!

 Report Review

Review #25, by coffee The Sorting Hat

25th April 2005:
haha! that's so cute, would love to see something like that. hope you keep going

Author's Response: i am awaiting chapter two to get validated!

 Report Review
If this is your story and you wish to respond to reviews, please login

<Previous Page  Jump:     Next Page>