{reviewid: 2753328, reviewer: 'Nessa%20Elendil'}
18th November 2012:
Great story. =] I liked it.
Author's Response: Thank you :) I'm very honored to hear that, I am a big fan.
 Report Review |
{reviewid: 1893249, reviewer: 'Nessa%20Elendil'}
12th April 2008:
Great beginning! 10/10
Report Review |
{reviewid: 1815003, reviewer: 'Nessa%20Elendil'}
1st February 2008:
Wow, not really how I pictured Mandos though... or his Hall...
Author's Response: Well, okay... I really didn't know how to picture Mandos... lol, I had a lot of trouble with that. Thanks, mellon!
Report Review |
{reviewid: 1766210, reviewer: 'Nessa%20Elendil'}
26th December 2007:
Hm. . . Interesting.
Author's Response: Thanks!
Report Review |
{reviewid: 1761685, reviewer: 'Nessa%20Elendil'}
22nd December 2007:
Good story. Some things seem to be happening a little fast, but other than that... 10/10
Author's Response: sorry, but thanks for reviewing
Report Review |
{reviewid: 1729809, reviewer: 'Nessa%20Elendil'}
27th November 2007:
Um... Wow... Very... insightful.
Author's Response: Insightful?! Is it a compliment? lol
Report Review |
{reviewid: 1710468, reviewer: 'Nessa%20Elendil'}
13th November 2007:
I love this!
Author's Response: Thanks soo much for the review! I love your stories and you happen to be one of my favorite authors! This is going up on the *review hall of fame*
Report Review |
{reviewid: 1660851, reviewer: 'Nessa%20Elendil'}
8th October 2007:
Interesting.
Author's Response: Thank you very much!
I'm very glad you liked it :)
Quill88
Report Review |
{reviewid: 1660845, reviewer: 'Nessa%20Elendil'}
8th October 2007:
This is sweet.
Author's Response: Thank you :)
I'm glad you see it as such, because that's what I wanted to show :)
thank you for reviewing!
Quill88
Report Review |
{reviewid: 1656870, reviewer: 'Nessa%20Elendil'}
6th October 2007:
That was amazing, I love it! It's excellent as a one-shot, but would make an incredible novel length story... That probably didn't do much for the length decision, lol. Well, anywho, 10/10!
Author's Response: Wow! THanks. *blush* and I've decided to go with novella.
Report Review |
{reviewid: 1649255, reviewer: 'Nessa%20Elendil'}
29th September 2007:
That was good. I was just wondering about the "follow her anywhere" statement. Did you mean to the Undying Lands? Or like Beren and Luthien? Or both?
Author's Response: To the Havens, yeah... not exactly like Beren and Luthien. Oh, and another thing... ^_^ the Valar, and Eru are going to grant him the life of the Eldar!
Report Review |
{reviewid: 1642917, reviewer: 'Nessa%20Elendil'}
24th September 2007:
Great chapter!
Author's Response: Hey, Thanks for your review!! I loved your story about Harry's 1st Birthday... Written perfectly. I hope you will continue to read my story as more chapters appear on the site!
Thanks once again
Craig
Report Review |
{reviewid: 1637777, reviewer: 'Nessa%20Elendil'}
20th September 2007:
Poor Harry, though in a way he deserves it, no Elf should exhibit his behavior.
Author's Response: Yeah, I totally agree, Nessa! ^_^ Hannon le.
Report Review |
{reviewid: 1632483, reviewer: 'Nessa%20Elendil'}
16th September 2007:
So sad, yet so sweet! I love it!
Author's Response: Thanks!
Report Review |
{reviewid: 1601723, reviewer: 'Nessa%20Elendil'}
28th August 2007:
Aw, this is so sweet, hpfreak! I give it a 10/10
Report Review |
{reviewid: 1554551, reviewer: 'Nessa%20Elendil'}
5th August 2007:
This is hilarious! Keep up the superb writing! 10/10
Report Review |
{reviewid: 1502048, reviewer: 'Nessa%20Elendil'}
7th July 2007:
Good chapter.
Not at all, I just believe that the only persons... I guess the word would be qualified to write any LotR/Middle-earth bit of writing are JRR Tolkien and Christopher Tolkien; and I much prefer the Tolkien Middle-earth to anything that anyone else comes up with regarding Middle-earth/LotR. Of course I will continue to this fic. Namarie.
Author's Response: Hannon le, I agree, but I still like to have fun writing my fanfics. ^_^ Namarie, mellon.
Report Review |
{reviewid: 1501224, reviewer: 'Nessa%20Elendil'}
7th July 2007:
I don't usually read any kind of LotR fic, especially not HP/LotR crossover (for reasons I won't take up space with here), but this, for my opinion of these kind of fics, was good.
Author's Response: Really? Hannon le, I'm honored by the compliment. I hope you continue reading my fic. Once again, hannon le, mellon.
Report Review |
{reviewid: 1443570, reviewer: 'Nessa%20Elendil'}
1st June 2007:
cute
Author's Response: thanks :)
Report Review |
{reviewid: 1226573, reviewer: 'Nessa%20Elendil'}
12th December 2006:
YEA!! new chapter!! HILARIOUS!!! lolxinfinity plz update again soon 10/10
Report Review |
{reviewid: 1194015, reviewer: 'Nessa%20Elendil'}
12th November 2006:
i love this! wonderfully written, going on my favs
Report Review |
{reviewid: 1191314, reviewer: 'Nessa%20Elendil'}
10th November 2006:
i really love your fic!! wicked awsome! 10/10 but i just want to point out that alecto is the sister and amycus is the brother. but awsome ch! update soon!
Author's Response: Aww, thanks :] :] I’m glad you like it :] :] Eek, really? I might go back and edit that as I do love to keep it canon! Thanks for telling me, I really appreciate it :] Oh and thanks for the wonderful review!! I’ll be updating on Friday :] :]
Report Review |
{reviewid: 1134801, reviewer: 'Nessa%20Elendil'}
11th September 2006:
LOL, that was great!! i love it!
Report Review |
{reviewid: 1134789, reviewer: 'Nessa%20Elendil'}
11th September 2006:
love it, really sad (makes me wanna cry), but i still love it. update soon!
Report Review |
{reviewid: 1132682, reviewer: 'Nessa%20Elendil'}
9th September 2006:
wow, that's...different. but still good...
and HILARIOUS! lol
Report Review |
