Reading Reviews From Member: narieth
  
4 Reviews Found

Review #1, by nariethMemories of a Madman: Snape and Lily, Harry Potters greatest love story

10th October 2012:
Beautiful! Grief and guilt, somewhat selfish, he remebers everything and will never let go. I think he was walking in the Hogwarts grounds in winter, Harry's 3 year, on or before Lily's birthday. He never understood why she didn't step aside, though wishes he could exchange his life for Lily's. He was and will be blind to such things as he never seen real family love.

 Report Review

Review #2, by nariethThe Truth is a Terrible Thing: The Truth is a Terrible Thing

10th October 2012:
Touching. Indeed I always thought that he wasn't right about treating Harry like that. He had to understand that Lily died for Harry, that she lives through him. His and James conflict never had anything to do with Harry. He was selfish. He was trying to do something to overcome his guilt. He was nasty and selfish, though he was loyal and brave. He can be understood and forgiven, but he will never forgive himself. He lived the past and that's he's problem.

 Report Review

Review #3, by nariethPranking the Marauders: Pranking the Marauders

30th August 2012:
Great! I liked your story. I would love to see that one. Especially Snape really smiling, sounds like the end of the world actually. Only one thing- wouldn't Lily be upset about Longbottom and his friends getting pranked?

 Report Review

Review #4, by nariethRape/Sexual Assault Reference Tutorial: Rape/Sexual Assault Reference Tutorial

14th August 2012:
Well this is very sad but, well she was really an IDIOT, I must say. She's a WITCH! And she couldn't handle a muggle boy... Sirius is very nice, although can't quite see him in this sitiuation. But it's an example. Though your writting is very good. Especially when written to fit something.

 Report Review
If this is your story and you wish to respond to reviews, please login