Reading Reviews From Member: ScarletRoses
46 Reviews Found

Review #1, by ScarletRosesThe Keeper's Daughter: The Alumni Game

12th November 2015:
I LOVED how you brought in the Keep Away/Hide & Seek there! It was amazing! I am tempted to go back and re-read those now!!

Brilliant chapter! I wish we would have gotten the talk, but I'm sure it's coming ;)


 Report Review

Review #2, by ScarletRosesThe Keeper's Daughter: Chemistry

4th September 2015:
WHY DO YOU HURT ME WITH COMPLICATIONS?! Agh. I felt the knife digging into Gee with that ending to the chapter. Take the knife OUT!!! TAKE IT OUT!!


Poor Gee.

 Report Review

Review #3, by ScarletRosesLethargic: But It Shouldn't Matter

10th July 2015:
Oh. My. Gosh. So, hello there! I was goign to just speed read to the most recent chapter because I'm a horrible person and I don't review on every chapter I read (and I do apologize for that), but THEN I saw you put "Harry Porter" in here.

Which is super hilarious. My husband's VERY close friend from high school is named Harry Porter. I kid you not. He got made fun of ALL the time. He would insist his name was Harrold so people would not call him Harry Potter. xD!

Author's Response: I understand not reviewing every chapter. It gets tedious, especially when I missed multiple updates somehow...

I'm glad that you like Harry Porter. I also feel very sorry for your husband's friend. I can't even imagine how much he must have hated that.

Thank you for your review and I have just released another chapter if you're interested!

 Report Review

Review #4, by ScarletRosesThe Keeper's Daughter: Downward Spiral

25th February 2015:
I absolutely love that you addressed Leo in your author's note and your "you do you" comment. It is hard to believe there are still people sensitive about that sort of thing, but there really is. Love is love. And I think you held yourself extremely well in your author's note by not telling the person off. I would have.

BUT GREAT CHAPTER!!! Gee needs to beat the crap out of Matteo. More than just smashing glass on his hand. Albus should kick him off the team. Yes, yes.


 Report Review

Review #5, by ScarletRosesDecoding the Tutshill Tornados: The One with all the Love

6th February 2015:
OHMYGOODNESS. No. It can't be coming to an end. That just isn't right. I'll cry. I promise you, I'll cry. I let my television babysit my newborn child because I need to read your story (which is something I'm actually totally against, but whatever. This is important).



But my Mason is ten times better than the twit Mason. Just sayin'.

 Report Review

Review #6, by ScarletRosesNo Solid Ground: I want to hide the truth; I want to shelter you

4th December 2014:
So over the course of three days, breastfeeding in between chapters, and ignoring my ever growing list of things I have to do, I read this whole entire story.


I hate not knowing what is going to happen. GIVE ME MORE!


 Report Review

Review #7, by ScarletRosesDecoding the Tutshill Tornados: The One with the Cage

25th November 2014:
You are amazing. I'm sure everyone tells you that but... you're amazing. I love the way you write James and the way he still has humor in every single moment of his life. I love that you make him cheeky in every single paragraph. I just love this story.

Purely amazing.


 Report Review

Review #8, by ScarletRosesThe Keeper's Daughter: Fragile

9th October 2014:
Brilliant! Per usual of course. I feel almost bad for Gee when it comes to Matteo. I just have this sinking feeling that he is going to let all of this get to his head..


 Report Review

Review #9, by ScarletRosesDecoding the Tutshill Tornados: The One with St. Mungos

31st July 2014:
Oh poor Freddie!!! UGH it tore my heart open. Like ripped straight down the middle.

But I'm so glad that it made James realize life is short and that he needs to talk to his parents and pull his resources in on this. Go Jamey.

 Report Review

Review #10, by ScarletRosesTug Of War: The Truth Part II

19th June 2014:
NO! I just read this in two days and went to click the next button AND THERE ISN'T ONE!

Do you realize how sad that is? :(


 Report Review

Review #11, by ScarletRosesAgainst the Odds: Kiss Me

16th June 2014:
So I've never been into pregnancy stories. I really hated them. Now that I am on my second child, I found myself debating reading this story. It has popped up so many times, I just haven't ever clicked it.

And I am SO glad I did. You capture pregnancy extremely well. I seriously broke a button on my pants a couple weeks ago and thought I was an oaf. Plus, I'm at 16 weeks myself, so Vi and I are very close in our pregnancies ;).

You have a true talent in your writing. I was laughing, tearing up, and smiling at everything. Please keep going. Its absolutely an amazing story and I am SO glad that I finally gave a pregnancy story chance.


Author's Response: Well, I am extremely glad you broke your pregnancy-story-strike to read this one! It's so exciting you and Violet are close in your pregnancies, I'm glad you find some solace in her trials and tribulations. Thank you so much for your kind words. Best of luck and congratulations! x

 Report Review

Review #12, by ScarletRosesFluorescent Adolescent : it's cold outside

9th June 2014:
Awwwhhh James and Effy!! I love it!! Yay!!! Keep them together, yeah? I like them better this way ;)

Author's Response: hahaha I'll try! thank you so much for this review xx

 Report Review

Review #13, by ScarletRosesFluorescent Adolescent : unbroken and wild

20th May 2014:
Awh. It was happy! Then it was sad! Then.. err.. maybe possibly happy again? Can they make sweet sweet love, please? I would enjoy that greatly... in a not creepy way... oh boy, I better quit while I'm ahead.

Author's Response: HAHAHAHAH i would love that too! and it is definitely not creepy (and if it was, we can be creepy together.) thank you so much for the review!

 Report Review

Review #14, by ScarletRosesThe Keeper's Daughter: Honesty

19th May 2014:
Oh I loved it. Al seems like a stand up guy. I like his class. He is a good captain, honestly probably better than Gee would be (don't tell her I said that or I may get murdered). Matteo.well.yeah. He needs to learn to play so Gryffindor doesn't lose to Slytherin. 'Nuff said on that note.

 Report Review

Review #15, by ScarletRosesThe Keeper's Daughter: It's going to be fine, you know

19th May 2014:
I'm super super excited to see everyone's reactions to Gee telling them she wont be playing. Especially Matteos, for some reason. I'm curious if he's as fit as I want Al to be... hmm..

 Report Review

Review #16, by ScarletRosesThe Keeper's Daughter: It Happened in August

19th May 2014:
It is quite refreshing to have some Wood back in our lives!! The people... get your mind out of the gutter, sheesh.

 Report Review

Review #17, by ScarletRosesFluorescent Adolescent : little sisters

14th May 2014:
This is the first story that has caught my interest in a VERY long time. I'm SUPER excited and into it! I wish Effy and Al would have liked each other. That would've led for a much more interesting love triangle. Oh well, James can win her heart ;)

Author's Response: omg wow thank you so much! al is too easy-going and mellow for effy, they could never have been anything more than friends- but that doesn't mean that future love triangles won't spring up (nudge nudge) (wink wink) thanks again for this review! xx

 Report Review

Review #18, by ScarletRosesDecoding the Tutshill Tornados: The One with the Tea Party

13th July 2013:
Awh this one was for me. Yiippiee :D.
My husband still doesn't understand the name and I don't know how to tell him :/.
Can they just have babies. Please? James and Aves babies would be adorbs. nuff said.

Author's Response: FOR YOU.

They really would be adorable, wouldn't they? Seriously. They would. They're both cute. I already know how many kids they'll have and what they'll have.

Thank you!

 Report Review

Review #19, by ScarletRosesDecoding the Tutshill Tornados: The One with the Family Wager

3rd June 2013:
So I have a confession, Mistress. I am very embarrassed to admit this, but my dog's name is Bink. I got him last April (which just goes to show how long I've been reading your work). I get asked all the time where I got the name from and I say "Oh, a book" and they say "what book?" and I try to play it off with a "Oh, you don't know it". Those are the times when I run across someone who has a library in their house and owns every book to mankind and doesn't believe me that they don't know it. I had just fallen in love with the character (and the name). I'm just sick of people calling him "Binky" or "Binks". Bink is a manly name. Even if he is a Pomeranian.

Author's Response: Ohmygosh you've just made my day. I would like to be the one to tell you Bink does come from a book. It comes from "A Spell for Chameleon" by Piers Anthony. So now you can tell anyone who asks that it's from that book. When I read that book, I absolutely fell in love with the name. "Binks" sounds like Binx from Hocus Pocus, actually.

So glad you like the name as much as I do :) You definitely just made my day!

 Report Review

Review #20, by ScarletRosesWelcome To The League: Week Two

25th April 2013:
So, I am very into this story. Its witty, comical, and very different. I haven't seen anything like this on HPFF (and I've been on it for a while). I love the fact that you designed it after the show, the League. if that's what you did...which I'm very sure you did... anyways, brilliant! Keep it up:D

Author's Response: Lord, I love that show. I don't think I've ever laughed so hard in my life. I'm glad you're enjoying it and I hope to write more soon! Thanks so much for reading and reviewing!

 Report Review

Review #21, by ScarletRosesBreaking the Quidditch Code: You're a Quidditch Player

24th July 2012:
So. Freaking. Perfect. Nuff said. I honestly loved this chapter the most. Poor James. I want him to play professional Quidditch so bad! I hate Avery's father. Can you stick me in the story for two seconds so I can Emerson-punch him? K thanks.

Author's Response: Aw, thank you so much! This was definitely one of my favorites in the story. So much fun to write. I'll put in a good word for you to get in the story. That would make everything much easier, wouldn't it? Thanks!

 Report Review

Review #22, by ScarletRosesBang: Harry Potter should never be unleashed in a kitchen.

8th July 2012:
oh good lord, a PLOT?! save us now. who needs plots nowadays anyways? you just need Aimee's snarky attitude and James's big head and you're golden. Anyways, loved it, of course. Keep it up!

Author's Response: YES. A PLOT. who knew this story was ever going to get one?! james' big head certainly makes the story more interesting ;) thank you so much for such a lovely review!

ellie :) xx

 Report Review

Review #23, by ScarletRosesBreaking the Quidditch Code: She's the Talent

1st July 2012:
jaslkfdjdklfjdsklfjda eff! I kept thinking you were going to have Avery come in and say they snogged before the Hufflepuff game. Would've been freaking perfect! I'm super excited for the sequel, but not super excited to see BTQC end. When one door closes, another opens, right?

Author's Response: It would have been hilarious, wouldn't it? So funny. You're right, thouhg. Another opens. DTTT to be exact. I hope you like the end and the sequel! The things I'm already cooking up are insane. Thanks!

 Report Review

Review #24, by ScarletRosesHormones: Wants, Needs, and Escapes

24th June 2012:
WHAT IS FREDDIE GOING TO DO?! Freddie would make a fantastic dad, just saying. Teaching it to play pranks on Ryan ;D. I can't say I'd be too fond of a pregnant Ryan, let alone Ryan-mom. She scares the bajezus out of me. Needless to say, another knock out of the park, Mistress.

Author's Response: He really would make a fantastic dad. And yes, pregnant Ryan is going to be ... interesting. She's terrifying. Heck, she even scares me! Thank you so much!

 Report Review

Review #25, by ScarletRosesHide and Seek: Epilogue

11th June 2012:
OH MY LORD. What am I supposed to do now without Hide and Seek? I've read this through and through and I do have to say that Oliver is one of my favorite characters now! Him and Jane have just been so damn cute and romantic in their own way that you can't help but love this story to pieces. It makes me so sad that it is all over. I do think you should make a one shot of Jane and Oliver down the road. Maybe even a short story collection? That's on you I suppose :D.

Author's Response: Aw, thank you! It really makes me sad that it is over too. I was pondering a one-shot down the road. When I really start to miss them. Maybe do one down the road when Jane is pregnant or when theyre married. Something light and funny. Probably when I'm rereading either story. I really appreciate you sticking with me through this! I hope you enjoy the other stories I have posted. Thanks!

 Report Review
If this is your story and you wish to respond to reviews, please login

<Previous Page  Jump:     Next Page>