HarryPotterFanfiction.com :: 80,000 Harry potter stories and podcasts

Reading Reviews From Member: Enigmaticrose4

6 Reviews Found

Review #1, by Enigmaticrose4

5th June 2011:

I love how you're setting up the relationships here, it's very well done. Again, you have some typos, but nothing major. Though, when you said "my James" instead of "by James" I couldn't help but laugh. :D

I hope you're able to get another chapter up soon, this is definitely worth continuing to read.

Report Review

Review #2, by Enigmaticrose4

And So We Lived: And So We Meet

5th June 2011:

I'm loving the friendly, yet dramatic atmosphere you're giving this story. Sirius is the perfect narrator for this. You did have a few typos though, but that was all.

Report Review

Review #3, by Enigmaticrose4

And So We Lived: Prologue

5th June 2011:

I'm finding this to be rather intriguing, and your writing is very good, so, I do believe I'm convinced to move on to the next chapter :)

Report Review

Review #4, by Enigmaticrose4

My Notebook Will Explain: Meet Me at the Lake

5th October 2010:

This is good, but I can definitely tell that it's one of your first pieces.

Report Review

Review #5, by Enigmaticrose4

My Notebook Will Explain: Help Us, Lily

5th October 2010:

Didn't she give away who she is with this line?

So, I transfigured the paper clip into a lily since it is indeed my favorite flower, even if it is my name

Report Review

Review #6, by Enigmaticrose4

My Notebook Will Explain: The Pen Pal Project

4th October 2010:

I know this is one of your early works, but of all the stories you had it sounded the most interesting to me. Your writing is good in this, but your spelling and grammar is atrocious. I'm assuming that all of your recent stories are much better.

You're a good writer. :)

Report Review

If this is your story and you wish to respond to reviews, please login