{reviewid: 2759006, reviewer: 'dlongbottom'}
16th December 2012:
Since JK did not tell us much about what went on at Hogwarts during this time I'm glad that you have.I think your story here is spot on.
Author's Response: Thank you. Funny, I was just (ten minutes ago!) reading an interview where JKR mused that she wouldn't mind doing a 'director's cut' of one or two of the Potter books where she had to leave out some things. I wonder if she ever wrote anything more for the 7th year at Hogwarts?
Report Review |
{reviewid: 2758982, reviewer: 'dlongbottom'}
16th December 2012:
Another great chapter,again I'll say you've really captured the reality of the book by JK.
Author's Response: thanks! :)
Report Review |
{reviewid: 2758930, reviewer: 'dlongbottom'}
15th December 2012:
Hippo you're an excellant writer.You've captured JK's style and mood.
Author's Response: Thank you - that's what I aim for, though I've still a long way to go. :)
Report Review |
{reviewid: 2758862, reviewer: 'dlongbottom'}
15th December 2012:
Good.I agree with the decisions you've made.The story thus far is well written and absolutely believable.I noticed your spelling is British,are you?
Author's Response: Thank you. Yes, I'm British so Britspeak and spelling throughout. :)
Report Review |
{reviewid: 2758845, reviewer: 'dlongbottom'}
15th December 2012:
Excellant first chapter very intriguing,love that medallion, nice touch.
Author's Response: Thanks - that first chapter is perhaps my favourite - I sometimes re-read it myself. What a sad git, I am! ;)
Report Review |
{reviewid: 2753695, reviewer: 'ias98'}
21st November 2012:
I love the second love story going on. Neville and Luna make the cutest couple.
And I love the story!
Author's Response: Thank you. Glad you're enjoying it. Much more to come!
Report Review |
{reviewid: 2752228, reviewer: 'freedom153'}
12th November 2012:
i really liked it hope others like it too
Author's Response: Thank you for your support! :) I'm glad you are enjoying the story. Next chapter being prepared and should be finished within a week or 10 days hopefully.
Report Review |
{reviewid: 2739937, reviewer: 'DarbyMHerlong'}
14th September 2012:
Harry heard Luna's voice! I did not see that coming! Good twist!
Author's Response: Yes, and the reason is that although Ginny is in deep shock she can hear Luna's voice so they are in her mind when her lips touch the medallion so those are the words conveyed to Harry's medallion.
Report Review |
{reviewid: 2739936, reviewer: 'DarbyMHerlong'}
14th September 2012:
I love how perceptive Luna is in your story. You didn't overdo it. She is very believable.
Author's Response: I think I've made Luna a little too clever sometimes! But then she is a Ravenclaw and Hermione is only a Gryffindor so she ought to be smarter than Hermione.
Report Review |
{reviewid: 2739935, reviewer: 'DarbyMHerlong'}
14th September 2012:
Haha. "Those two read a lot." Very funny. :) I loved how Luna talked circles around Prof Snape!
Author's Response: Double post but I'm responding to keep my responses zeroised! :)
Report Review |
{reviewid: 2739934, reviewer: 'DarbyMHerlong'}
14th September 2012:
Haha. "Those two read a lot." Very funny. :) I loved how Luna talked circles around Prof Snape!
Author's Response: I like Lavender's line that comes just after that:
"I've found this lovely old book about, erm..." (looks at book to remind herself!)
Report Review |
{reviewid: 2739932, reviewer: 'DarbyMHerlong'}
14th September 2012:
I love your story! I am just so amazed at your talent and how much effort you went to to put the story into the correct chronology! Belching powder? BRILLIANT :) JK would be so proud! I will be so disappointed if there is no ending.
Author's Response: Thanks. If there is no ending then you know I'm a prisoner in Azkaban so send help please! There is no way I'm going to abandon this story lightly; I've already written an important chapter far ahead and I can't wait to finish all the ones in between and post it.
Report Review |
{reviewid: 2735977, reviewer: 'Lumos_x'}
30th August 2012:
Hi! My favourite part of this chapter was Neville finally asking out Hannah! I liked that you included that, since you don't find out anything from the books, because it's all from Harry's POV. Oh, that's another thing I enjoyed - reading it from Ginny's perspective, with your own bits added in of course (the medallions.)
I also love the way you write Luna and how she is happy to observe a conversation, and then suddenly join in with a unexpected remark.
I thought that adding in the bit about old magic breaking the new when Harry and Ginny kiss was a nice touch. We know that Dumbledore is a great believer in love, and it seemed fitting. :)
Lumos_x
Author's Response: Thank you for your feedback; glad you are enjoying the story.
Yes, the 'kissing gate' idea was fun - two young lovers separated only by an infinitesimally-thin enchantment!
It's great that you like my take on Luna. She's quirky but she's not in Ravenclaw for nothing! She's intuitively-wise and her unusual way of looking at life gives her insights that others miss.
Report Review |
{reviewid: 2728851, reviewer: 'HappyMollyWeasley'}
7th August 2012:
Oh, I get the feeling that this will be a really good story! I like this first chapter very much! :-)
Author's Response: Thank you. Hope you enjoy the rest of it! :)
Report Review |
{reviewid: 2728234, reviewer: 'Marauding%20hippogriff'}
5th August 2012:
This is such a sweet story. I reckon you have to be right-there's no way Harry could've just left Ginny like he did, something had to have happened. Thoroughly enjoying it so far :)
Author's Response: Thanks - glad you're enjoying it. Next chapter up very soon.
Report Review |
{reviewid: 2723189, reviewer: 'no%20one'}
21st July 2012:
amazing. I loved it and I can't wait to read
more.
Author's Response: Thank you. No need to wait! More chapters already up there and another on its way in a few days.
Report Review |
{reviewid: 2723176, reviewer: 'Magicalis%20Writer'}
21st July 2012:
Again, amazing! You are such a skilled writer! :)
Author's Response: Many thanks! That's very encouraging! :)
Report Review |
{reviewid: 2723173, reviewer: 'Magicalis%20Writer'}
21st July 2012:
That was really good! Love the idea of the Lover's Medallion... :) Reading on!
Author's Response: Thanks! - the medallion plays an important role throughout the story to keep Harry and Ginny in touch.
Report Review |
{reviewid: 2718584, reviewer: 'Amy'}
11th July 2012:
I love it so far! i also love how you've kept it canon. when's the next chapter coming?!? xo
Author's Response: Thank you. :) I'm hoping to post the next chapter this evening or tomorrow at the latest then I think it's about 2 days wait for validation at the moment.
Report Review |
{reviewid: 2707733, reviewer: 'JellyBellyEmily'}
12th June 2012:
Awesome story! The beginning pulled me in really quickly! I can't wait for an update! 10/10
-Em
Author's Response: Thank you! Next chapter should go public in a few days. :)
Report Review |
{reviewid: 2707593, reviewer: 'ginnyHPfan'}
12th June 2012:
That's sweet and it's better than harry simply staring at the the mauauders map watching her move around the castle. i always hated the fact that they broke up
Author's Response: Thank you. Yes, I think their relationship was diluted too much in the original. Harry may be noble but love will find a way. Next chapter up soon. :)
Report Review |