Report a Review

This service is designed to allow HPFF users to alert the staff about inappropriate reviews.

Review:sidrocks123 says:
I don't know if you still remember my reviews or not, but anyways -
I am still not able to give a rating above 10.
Even though it's been almost a year since reading this piece of art, your writing still hasn't deteriorated in any way. In fact, I don't even know what to say anymore about this story. It has remained in my heart as the first story ever to bind me in its entirety and its completeness, and it looks like it will not let me go anytime soon. Why? How can you write such a story that is so.. so.. magnificent, as well as emotional at the same time? I was bogged down by college, then the death of a close relative of mine, then a hairline fracture on my right hand, but I think I do not regret waiting for a year before reading all of Year 5, 6 and 7, as it just gave me another excuse to read the story all over again. And twice. And.. you get the general idea.
This is like the ultimate story - it has infinite replay value. Most of the stories I have read, the movies and TV shows that I have watched, are good in the first viewing, fell okayish by the second, and fizzle out almost completely by the third. 19 Years is a story which you can never get bored with - Ever. I don't even remember the number of times I have read this particular book cover to cover, but what I do remember that I was stunned after every time I had finished reading it.
This is a time where I feel so sad for the fact that fanfiction cannot be published due to legal grievances. If it was, the book would have remained a permanent fixture in my bookshelf, for a long, long time.
I don't even know why anybody, or even you, are surprised with the Dobby Awards nomination. I wanted to nominate the story for it ever since it was published. It was that good.
Sorry for the long review, but it is hard to explain why this story makes me feel I'm in heaven. The amount of feels it gives me... surreal.

Author's Response: How could I forget? You are always so lovely to me!!

it makes me so happy to hear you're still enjoying the story! I feel like I don't deserve all those kind words but just know how much it means to me that you feel that way about my writing. I guess when you write something you can only dream that someone won't think it's too bad. So hearing all this.. it's amazing. I am so, so sorry about everything you've had to go through lately. Sending you lots of hugs over the internet!

It's ao incredible to me that you would read this again, and still enjoy it as much - thank you so, so much. You never fail to make me smle and this review is no exception. It's a dream of mine to get a story published one day, so you wanting this on your bookshelf is just unreal! (if it DOES happen one day it's obviously going to be original fiction, but still). Thank you again!

Please don't apologize for writing long reviews- they are the best. And you are the best. Your reviews give me so many feels it's surreal. Thank you thank you thank you! XXx

Your Name:
Reason for this Report:

  • The review is offensive.
  • The review is spam or chit-chat (not actually a review).
  • The review was double posted.
  • The review has formatting problems.
Repeat the number: 648
Submit Report: