Report a Review

This service is designed to allow HPFF users to alert the staff about inappropriate reviews.

Review:marauderfan says:
Nooo Laurel! I had a feeling this would happen, this is not the right way to combat her depression. And Tristan, idiot, that's not the best thing to do right after she just got out of REHAB FOR SPELLS AGHH. Both of these characters, I really just want to shake some sense into them.

Ahhh his stereo is fixed AND works in the castle! Isobel is so wonderful to him. Music is a good outlet for Tristan, because it's the only thing that makes him have any emotion at all, and it's not destructive. I could see Tristan being in a band. Except that would probably turn out badly for him because of all the destructive behaviours that would inevitably occur when they go on tour. But I digress.

Aw, I like that Emily is trying to encourage Laurel in her hobby of bracelet making when Laurel doesn't find much else to be interesting. Why would the twins bring her a potentially poisonous thing from Snape's office? I worry what Laurel will try to do with it in her current state.

Nononono not Tristan and Laurel! I mean yeah, they're both kind of messed up people so they have that in common but NOOO. This is just going to destroy Emily, and the group dynamic, and ughh. Stupid hormones. Stupid Tristan. Stupid Laurel.

Ok, when even self-involved TRISTAN notices that Isobel isn't eating, then she should know she has a problem. OPEN YOUR EYES WOMAN. I think she's still denying it's even a problem, she genuinely thinks she's under control. What I wonder is, when she finally does realise she's got a problem, will she ask for help or just try to handle it on her own? :-/ I'm glad both Tristan and Emily are drawing attention to it though.

The comment Emily made about Laurel being oblivious to what's going on with her friends was so twistedly ironic as she herself has no idea what's been going on behind the scenes with Laurel and Tristan. Poor Emily.

I understand Tristan's frustration at Professor Sprout for trying to get him to talk about his feelings - maybe he just needs someone to be there to listen even when he doesn't talk. LIKE EMILY. Tristan going on at the end about how he's too messed up for Emily makes me sad, because he needs a little bit of Sunshine in his dark life.

Heh, sorry for all the shouting at your characters in this review. It's not directed at you, I promise. :P

House Cup Review 2014

Author's Response: Oh I'm glad for your response to that! I definitely didn't want anyone to be shipping them.

Haha, I think Tristan would be pretty awful in a band :p He would spend most of the time laboring over the 'influences,' and the result would be an absolute mess. He's definitely more of a fan of music than a creator of music.

Eeeh! Everyone's presents to her definitely said more about themselves than about Laurel. Isobel gives her beauty products, Tristan gives her music (which she would play on, what?), and only Emily gives her the things that Laurel herself wants and needs. Aand, the twins give her stolen things, just because.

Feel free to shout at them! I definitely wanted to mirror OotP--I shouted at Harry so much inside my own head :)


Your Name:
Reason for this Report:

Examples:
  • The review is offensive.
  • The review is spam or chit-chat (not actually a review).
  • The review was double posted.
  • The review has formatting problems.
Repeat the number: 242
Submit Report: