Report a Review

This service is designed to allow HPFF users to alert the staff about inappropriate reviews.

Review:Guest says:
SO Rose is mad that Scorpius lied about his wife? Did she not fail to tell Scorpius that she pretty much was attached to Rex? and wasn't it her that shattered his heart in the first place because she didn't care about him enough? I mean considering she hardly ever spoke to her family anyway it seems stupid that she continued to hurt Scorpius. It isn't fair to her, Scorpius and especially not Rex that she is in love with Scorpius but not only refuses to be with him but slept with him knowing she was going to be dating some other guy when she knew it would hurt him to do so. She is completely heartless!! I honestly have never hated a character more and the sad part is that she tries to act like she's all innocent in the matter

Author's Response: She was never attached to Rex when Scorpius came to New York. She is allowed to have an ex boyfriend she didn't know he was going to show up, and it is even directly stated that Rose would have told Scorpius if she had known he was coming, and she was pretty honest about the aspects of their relationship. Not to mention her and Rex started hooking up because she found out about Scorpius engagement, there was never supposed to be anything serious between them. But Rex got serious, and that was when things have changed. Rose did care about him she loved him dearly but can I point out that it is scary to not know what's going on at seventeen. She has admitted it before she was scared and she ran. It had nothing to do about not caring for Scorpius. And yes she broke his heart but she broke hers as well. She spoke to her family quite a bit she just hasn't seen them. In later chapters you will get some clarification on her feelings of the situation. Also she gave Scorpius the option to stop she said, "I will have to leave," making it pretty clear that sleeping together wouldn't change a thing and to be honest Scorpius knew that well in advance anyways, he never once considered that Rose and him would sleep together and things would magically fall into place. Give him some credit he's not a complete idiot. And he slept with her knowing that he was married to another woman, even if they were separated is it alright to sleep with someone elses husband? She has never once tried to act like she is all innocent in the matter, she is innocent about Scorpius being a jerk who lied to her, that is her opinion to have, like I said before she has always been completely honest about everything I don't ever recall Scorpius asking her if she had been in a relationship, if he had asked she would have answered. She however did ask him directly why is it that he came and his response is Lexie left me, I'm sorry but that is pushing it. Not only not a good answer there are some glearing holes in his story. Now is she innocent in not standing up to her parents and fighting for Scorpius when she was SEVENTEEN years old, no she is not, and she has even said countless times that she knows that she is awful for not doing it. But she has fixed that and she has stood up to her father, she righted that wrong and as a result she has cut him out of her life, and I might add she did this after she had learned that Scorpius had lied to her.
I am happy that I have people who get so heated up on this story but I am going to request that you please try and look at it from Rose's perspective for a slight moment. And also may I ask if you hate her so much then why do you keep reading the story, I'm honestly just curious?


Your Name:
Reason for this Report:

Examples:
  • The review is offensive.
  • The review is spam or chit-chat (not actually a review).
  • The review was double posted.
  • The review has formatting problems.
Repeat the number: 119
Submit Report: