Report a Review

This service is designed to allow HPFF users to alert the staff about inappropriate reviews.

Review:AlexFan says:
I disagree with their decision to not come back. I mean I get that the thought of not having to do your exams is exciting and you want to take the opportunity to not do them but if they were what decided my career, as much as I hated exams, I'd still take them. What are they going to do if their music career doesn't take off. The show biz industry isn't exactly a solid job. You could be dropped the next day because everyone's moved into the next best thing.

Personally, I think the band made a really hasty reckless decision. They sure were excited to throw away their education that fast. And while Dom does have a point with Hermione, it doesn't mean it'll apply to everyone. Hermione helped save the world, letting her finish her schooling is the least the Wizarding world could do. I don't think Hogwarts would just let anyone come back and do their seventh year.

I know I sound really annoying and maybe even mean but I just can't get over the choice. Usually a decision like that takes some time to make because it determines the rest of your life.

And James needs to stop being so self-centered. Ally just isn't going to be at Hogwarts, it isn't like she's dumping him or anything. She'll come visit James whenever she can but he's not in the band and the decision really doesn't have much to do with him. It's not like he couldn't make a long distance relationship work, it'd be hard but it can be done.

I don't think Jamew fully realises that Ally's life doesn't revolve around his. I agree with her, she doesn't have to consult him about every decision that she makes.

And Ally really does have the worst timing. I wouldn't exactly suggest brining up the fact that you're not graduating school while smooching with your boyfriend.

I can tell that the academic and feminist in me is coming out in this review.

Author's Response: Aha yep I can see it too, in all honesty though they probably would have gone back its just me not wanting to write more of it but if you're interested Adam did do his newts outside of hogwarts and well I'd hope the band would have some success but a lot of people don't finish their education and they do fine ahhah but id had this planned for a while about them not coming back for 7th year and you just guessed the next chapter haha but thank you for reviewing and I hope I haven't annoyed you too much about it aha

Your Name:
Reason for this Report:

  • The review is offensive.
  • The review is spam or chit-chat (not actually a review).
  • The review was double posted.
  • The review has formatting problems.
Repeat the number: 633
Submit Report: