Report a Review

This service is designed to allow HPFF users to alert the staff about inappropriate reviews.

Review:soufflegirl99 says:
Okay, before I start, I just want to say how amazing and awesome this story is, and how it's probably the best Jily I've ever read, and I can say with confidence that quite a few people agree with me about that.

I loveee your portrayal of Remus - he's such an awesome cute character, and you're characterisation of him is just the best! The way he can reason with anybody reminded me of the relationship between him and Harry in the fifth book, and how like Sirius/James Harry was being. I think it was so moving the way you wrote about how Remus got turned, and it found it really touching, and I totally didn't have tears in my eyes...

The argument between James and Sirius was really unexpected and upredictible! But I think it was quite important, and showed how Sirius is actually really caring, not just for Belle, but towards all his friends. And I don't really have a side, as I agree with both of them - James should be a bit more considerate and keep a close eye on her, but he can't exactly always be next to her. I think it was really funny how Belle is sassy 24/7, and, on a side note, her and Sirius are unbelievabley cute together!

Eek! Can't believe there are only 4/5 chapters to go! I'm really sad about that, but so excited for the sequel! It's going to be awesome (but no pressure) :D Overall, another lovely and brilliant chapter, and I was pleased the pace was slower after last time's heart wrenching action one!

Sophie :D

Author's Response: Hi lovely face! How am I supposed to reply to the sweetness of that comment? I try so hard to hope that people are enjoying this and not convince myself they're just reading it to be nice, so the fact that you think it's a good Jily seriously just makes me want to hug you ♥

I loved that Sirius and James's argument showed how caring Sirius really is. I agree with them both too. I can't imagine being in either of the positions, but I'm happy you could see both sides of it! And that you think Belle and Sirius are cute together! I think so too, but I'm a little biased :P!

Awww haha you are so sweet Sophie. I hope the sequel does the kind of justice I want to their lives after Hogwarts, and the only reason I have the courage to write it is because of insanely sweet reviewers like you ♥

Thank you so much for another amazing review, Sophie! I love seeing you here. You spoil me!

Your Name:
Reason for this Report:

  • The review is offensive.
  • The review is spam or chit-chat (not actually a review).
  • The review was double posted.
  • The review has formatting problems.
Repeat the number: 752
Submit Report: