Report a Review

This service is designed to allow HPFF users to alert the staff about inappropriate reviews.

Review:acveby says:
I don't like the way Scorp talk about their past. He is not that insensitive, and to say he don't know how to react after knowing that Rose didnt tell Marc and Carla anything about her past is ridicule, because Scorp is smart and have cooller head than Rose. And things just happen too fast. Rose said that she will go out with some friend and invited Scorp to come, so did Scorp meet Marc and Carla before? Did he talked to them before? Or this is the first time they meet? To share information about their past to someone he just meet for the first time, it's not really Scorp.

Author's Response: A few of things, first he wasn't being insensitive when he talked about their past he is guiltburden and where as Rose prefers to clame shut about her past he still holds the insecurity of what he has done and that he should still have to pay the price for it, which is by being honest if people ask and allowing them to hate him, even if he doesn't deserve it feels that he has. (I know I didn't say all of that but I had hopped that I had gotten the guilty part across.)
Second how is it redicule? Scorpius is smart but he didn't know how to act after Matt and Carla left. If he had said he was sorry Rose wouldn't have listened and for all he knew Rose had told them about their past, Rose has distanced herself and whereas he used to know her every move he really doesn't anymore.
Next, he has been in town for two weeks and the topic of the conversation was ment to demonstrate that even though they have been apart for six years the same issues are there, neither one of them resolved anything when they left Hogwarts. And the reason Rose invited him to go is because unlike what some people seem to belive she isn't pure evil and she doesn't want to see him outcasted not to mention at one point in time they were friends and she knows that she can easily turn that side of her on, she is just scared to do it because of what might come after. Scorpius has mt Matt breifely, and hasn't met Carla, both Matt and Carla have mantained their distance for Rose's sake, she didn't ask them to do it, they just did as a gesture of loyalty to their friend.
As I said before Scorius will talk about his past if he is feeling guilty, and that night the thought of how he gave that scar to Rose is what set it in motion that he should still be paying for what he did and for that people should hate him. It has nothing to do with fact that Rose had taunted him or was equally involved in that fight but more to do with the fact that he had stouped so low and hurt someone that he truly does care about.
The third thing I want to point out is that the name is Matt not Marc.
Thank you for the review and I hope that that helped your confusion about the chapter. He wasn't being insensitive, he was being guilty.


Your Name:
Reason for this Report:

Examples:
  • The review is offensive.
  • The review is spam or chit-chat (not actually a review).
  • The review was double posted.
  • The review has formatting problems.
Repeat the number: 438
Submit Report: