Report a Review

This service is designed to allow HPFF users to alert the staff about inappropriate reviews.

Review:Izzi says:
Loved this chapter. But then again, I liked them all. (;

Finally meet 'little' Hugo! He's definitely different to most fics I've read about him, but I like it. Different is good. Actually, a lot of your characters are different from what you generally see. Might be why I like this story so much.

I also like that in the dorm she prefers the right window. I would too, if I was her.
The girls in her dorm seem like real idiots; those kinds of girls who only care about boys, and make up and such. Reminds me of some girls at my school, but I guess, you always have those ones where ever you go, even Hogwarts, it seems.

What's wrong with Scorpius? Why did he need distracting?
Rose is more open with Scorpius than she is with other people, I find, even if she doesn't necessarily notice. To me, it explains why she told him her hiding places, even if it was accidental and they do display some sort of hatred towards each other.
I have to say, I'm a sucker for stories too, and I loved the Slytherin one.

I still want to find out more about Georgina Morrish and what she has to do with McLaggen. As well as Scorpius and Rose's real feelings towards each other.

Keep updating! (:

Author's Response: Hello Izzi,

Thank you! I hope you like what is to come too.

Yesm we do get to meet 'little' Hugo and he will be featured more in future chapters. I'm very flattered that you think most of my characters are different to the usual stereotypes, it was what I was aiming for but I'm never quite sure if I manage it, so thank you very much indeed!

A view of the lake and the mountains or a view of some tiny, colour specks throwing a ball around? I think Rose has definitly chosen the right window. Her dormmates do seem like idiots and I know just the type you mean. We have them at my school to, they are everywhere... Even Hogwarts. But even idiotic looking people have their own story.

There does appear to be something up with poor Scorpius which will become apparent later on. I think Rose is more open with him than other people because he has no real connection to her. He's not her family, not in her dorm, not in her House. She doesn't seem to realise it though. I think she trusts him a little more than prehaps she should for someone she hardly knows. Even if he does like telling her stories.

Georgina Morrish will feature in future chapters, never fear. Her story shall be explained. As for Scorpius and Rose's feelings for each other... I think they probably still need to figure that out themselves first.

Thank you for a lovely review and the next chapter will be added to the queue either today or tomorrow so look out for it. Thanks again,

Irish Myth.

Your Name:
Reason for this Report:

  • The review is offensive.
  • The review is spam or chit-chat (not actually a review).
  • The review was double posted.
  • The review has formatting problems.
Repeat the number: 159
Submit Report: