Report a Review

This service is designed to allow HPFF users to alert the staff about inappropriate reviews.

Review:water_lily43175 says:
Oh, Albus, NEVER EAT A CHOCOLATE CAULDRON. Go speak to your Uncle Ron, he'll tell you all about it. Though in fairness, I did the same as him and just ASSUMED that whatever post he received would be from his parents, so I can see why he just went ahead and started eating them.

Swelling Solution. The Third Years have just brewed it. HMM.

You know, I'm not so sure that Slughorn would have believed the popular viewpoint regarding Voldemort's return. He was near enough on the run for the entire of OotP, remember? There's certainly a question over how much he DID know or believe, and he definitely didn't seem to give a damn about joining the cause, but ... he was wiser to it all than we think he should have been, I reckon. His heart's in the right place, he's just a typical Slytherin in terms of saving his own skin first.

Rose really doesn't think much of James, does she? I think he's telling the truth too; pranking Albus is by no means below him, but he wouldn't do anything SERIOUS. He'd just pull a harmless prank, and this is NOT a harmless prank. Mind you, setting training brooms on fire is hardly harmless! Way to disprove my point, James! Either way, I'm satisfied that it wasn't him. And I love how his first reaction was to ask if Al was ok :)

Hmm, Blackburn's in a better mood today. I'M NOT CONVINCED.

Author's Response: I actually laughed at the first two lines of your review. *huggles you super-tightly* And I'm glad somebody else thought as Albus did. SL was like "Albus, they are going to be dodgy!"

You've a good point about Slughorn. I hadn't actually thought of that. And I don't blame him for going on the run. I think I would have too. The Death Eaters are SCARY!

And yeah, Rose and James are sort of opposites. He's a bit of a joker and she's pretty serious. Plus she tends to get a bit carried away protecting those she loves. And Albus is a bit of an easy target, because he believes what James tells him so much.

The fire thing was partly an accident when he couldn't fully control his magic. He probably didn't intend to do that much harm.

And yes, Blackburn is in a better mood now. *giggles at how suspicious you and SL are of her*


Your Name:
Reason for this Report:

Examples:
  • The review is offensive.
  • The review is spam or chit-chat (not actually a review).
  • The review was double posted.
  • The review has formatting problems.
Repeat the number: 505
Submit Report: