Report a Review

This service is designed to allow HPFF users to alert the staff about inappropriate reviews.

Review:ohmymerlin says:


Oh. My. Gosh.

This is absolutely AMAZING!

Seriously, I just stared at it in awe for ages, it's a FANTASTIC one-shot!

I can't put the thoughts and feelings I have into words. It's THAT good!

I ADORE the way you wrote Sirius' anguish, it's so new and creative. I also LOVED the spin you put on his mother, we only see her as a ruddy old cow that doesn't care for her son at all. I absolutely loved that you didn't make her like that, you made her as an actual motherly figure!

It was so, so, so sad when he was writing to Regulus, waiting for a response. His letters were so heart-breaking, I just wanted to reach into the computer and hug him.

This one-shot is absolutely brilliant! I've never read anything as good as this! If the Dobby's were still here I would have nominated this! It's actually now my favourite one-shot on this site!

The last line:

The screams stop and for an infinitesimal moment, he wishes they didn't.

Really pulled at my heartstrings! It just finished the story so powerfully, it was just amazing!

Of course you get a 10/10! It's EXTREMELY well-written! :D

Author's Response: You actually made me blush SO much!!! You mentioning the Dobby's honestly made my day.. Thank you so much for that!! I've always wondered how it'd feel to be nominated for the Dobby's and you saying that is amazing!

I've always had this belief that mother could never, ever not love their child. You don't carry someone for 9 months inside of you and not feel something, anything for them, no matter how different they are to you.

Another belief of mine was that Sirius and Regulus had always had a profound, under-explored relationship and I thought letters would work :P

I love you SO much for leaving this review!!! Honestly!!! I had to stare at it and read it over and over again before I could reply to it :P


Your Name:
Reason for this Report:

  • The review is offensive.
  • The review is spam or chit-chat (not actually a review).
  • The review was double posted.
  • The review has formatting problems.
Repeat the number: 659
Submit Report: