Report a Review

This service is designed to allow HPFF users to alert the staff about inappropriate reviews.

Review:Cirque Du Freak says:
Gah, this is so pretty. After thinking about it I'd have to say that this is my next favourite one-shot of yours after WP.

They're almost alike in a way - the need to have cleanliness in their lives is something that stands out and the fact that they're both grieving in their own way still. Both important and poignant beyond compare.

There's something so lovely about Remus drinking tea and coffee for every person that he loved and lost in those moments. Commemorating them in a very special sort of way, but it breaks my heart the way he reminds himself of them every single day as if he could have done something to change the course of events. Reminding himself because he thinks about them anyway and sinking into this unhealthy depression where he does what he can to survive, but never tries to live.

And then the ever-present "we" of Remus and Sirius together. Because there can't be another relationship other than what they are when they're together. They are the way they are and there can't be any other way to it when they were young. They can't get passed that because too much has happened to them in their short lives and they're much too close for their own good.

Its only when Sirius comes back that it all changes and that last line when Remus sees what's become of them now. How everything has changed, because they believed different things in the past, but that some of those beliefs no matter how you try to get past them are always going to be the knife at neck.

Blah. I'm trying to say I really like this and its just coming out as some sort of running commentary of how my thoughts were when I read this. Ignore me. Love this.

Author's Response: So after this review I went through and read the whole thing all over again to see how it was going and, yeah, I forgot how much I'd loved writing this with all the ittle bits of the Maraudery goodness which I just LOVVEEE.

So many feels towards Remus/sirius and you know slash isn't usally like my thaanng so ah, so many feels towards this and I'm really glad you liked it (and I really like you) so thank you greatly for everything and just generally being totes wonderful.


Your Name:
Reason for this Report:

  • The review is offensive.
  • The review is spam or chit-chat (not actually a review).
  • The review was double posted.
  • The review has formatting problems.
Repeat the number: 430
Submit Report: