Report a Review

This service is designed to allow HPFF users to alert the staff about inappropriate reviews.

Review:claire says:
WAIT! QUESTION! IMPORTANT QUESTION! lol
this isnt a story where isabella's gonna end up with james after being engaged to al and having his baby right? LOL

i dunno, i kinda agree with rose. it sorta seems like he likes her. either that or Al has some big terrible secret that james knows about that he doesnt want his friend being hurt from.
so one or the other, thats my guess.

personally, im not sure which one i'm rooting for
i dislike the stories where the girl has to choose
between james and Al because it always pits the brothers against each other
and i dislike the idea of james and Al having a strained relationship because even though in the epilogue of DH james and al were "fighting"/"arguing", i cant see them be less than affectionate towards each other, just because of how i believe the potters are and it kills me whenever the brothers fight, for a GIRL.

obviously brothers are going to fight but i cant imagine that there ever being a point where james and al would not be on speaking or friendly terms, ya know what i mean?

it does make interesting read but it kills me.
on the inside. very slowly. LOL
but its true, it does kill me but im RLY curious xD

actually you know what,
i think im going to have to go with al having some secret that isabella doesnt know about LOL
oh the drama that would come with james liking isabella xD
though it rly seems like he does. CALLING OFF THE WEDDING?! only a bloke in love would say that
no one in their right minds would jump to that first conclusion lolll

anyways. im NimbusWombat16943 on pottermore. and im a gryffindor :D GO LIONS! haha

Author's Response: lol Don't worry, this is a Albus/OC story all the way. And the reason James does not like Al and Bella together has nothing to do with him liking Isabella!!
And I REALLY understand where you are coming from! But if James does end up being in love with her (not saying that he is), he would never do anything about it as long as she and Al are happy. :)

Thank you for this amazingly long review, I think its the longest one I have EVER gotten!! And even though you are a Gryffindor *sigh* I will friend you on Pottermore. lol

Thanks again!!!

~Claire



Your Name:
Reason for this Report:

Examples:
  • The review is offensive.
  • The review is spam or chit-chat (not actually a review).
  • The review was double posted.
  • The review has formatting problems.
Repeat the number: 890
Submit Report: