Report a Review

This service is designed to allow HPFF users to alert the staff about inappropriate reviews.

Review:witnesstoitall says:
Alright, so basically I have already told you a great portion of the things I'd normally comment on elsewhere. Nothing like live reviews. (H) I want to reiterate something I said there. You really do have a gift. I read a lot of the things you write, and you change styles and constructions beautifully and with very little apparent effort. Do me a favor and never forget how talented you are. This was gorgeous in it's simplicity. It was what, two thousand and some odd words? Maybe three? and you managed to capture a relationship better than some fics do in entire novels. I think the simplicity of it was what made it so effective (hoping I chose the right word there. my brain is muddled and I can't decide if I needed a noun or a verb... so NOUN YOU GOT). The bit about the thestral was spectacular. And I adore the bit about the sheer amount of orange in the RoR before the battle. It must have been all the more stressful knowing that literally his entire family was there in that battle risking their lives. The funeral, I can't even begin to comment on it or I'll get all worked up and teary again. I do not handle the immediate aftermath of Fred's death well (notice I start WAT like what, three full months later? I'm a sneakeh cheater that avoids the Feels). I think you did a marvelous job though and I'll leave it at that. Lastly, your closing line was tops.

That's all. I know this review was all mushy and you're going to answer something about being blobby, but I don't even care... I needed to be able to say all these things.

Keep up the spectacular work. If I can't have all your talents (which is a bit facetious of me), at least continue to share the product of them with me.


Author's Response: This is unfair in the highest. I just made a complete mess of responding to Sarah's review on this story /and now I have to make an attempt at yours/. I cry foul. ♥

Thank you so, so much for writing this for me. Endlessly. I cannot even begin to try and formulate responses to all of your wonderful compliments, just /thank you/ for encouraging me, and keeping me going, and just everything. Your reviews mean a lot to me. :)

GAHH. JUST THANK YOU. SERIOUSLY. I CANNOT SAY ANYTHING ELSE. ♥ ♥ Sorry for how rambly/nonsensical this was, but I do appreciate it!

Your Name:
Reason for this Report:

  • The review is offensive.
  • The review is spam or chit-chat (not actually a review).
  • The review was double posted.
  • The review has formatting problems.
Repeat the number: 355
Submit Report: