Report a Review

This service is designed to allow HPFF users to alert the staff about inappropriate reviews.

Review:Drobbles says:
Wow you really think what Marietta did is worse than everything Malfoy did? So you think getting her future husband and father to her children nearly killed is nothing compared to almost getting her expelled? Also Marietta only confessed because she was forced by Umbridge. Malfoy did most of his worst to Harry, Ron, and Hermione on his own, before sixth year.

Yes twenty years is a long time but so is seven years of torment that Malfoy put Ron, Harry, herself, Ginny, Neville, and many of their good friends. You really think twenty years and a "sorry, didn't I mention I love you" enough for her to actually believe him? Come on, think about it. I know it's romantic to think that one "I love you" is enough to fix everything but that's not how life works. Another thing, as I've mentioned in my other review Hermione is fiercely loyal. Do you really think that she would be so callous as to totally disregard how Ron feels? That she would just ignore all the years that Ron defended her from Malfoy? Or all the years that Malfoy tormented Ron? Maybe she will be able to forgive Malfoy for all he's done to her but do you really believe she will forgive him for all the horrible things he did to Ron? Or to Harry? Or to Neville?

I'm done here. I've said what I wanted to say. I doubt if I'll be able to convince authors that potray Hermione as this perfect person but I try my best. I love the Harry Potter characters as they are (yes Draco too, his cowardly evil is what makes him who he is) and it annoys me to no end when fic authors twist them (whether good or bad) so much that the characters are no longer the ones JKR wrote.

Author's Response: of course what Marietta did isn't as bad as Malfoy but before sixth year Malfoy didn't actually do anything that bad and it's not like Hermione didn't do anything; she slapped him.
This is not real life it's a story, not even a story just a one-shot so it doesn't have to mimick the outside world.
If you don't like people changing characters then why do you read fanfiction? People keep characters alive, make them marry other people because its the 'fans fiction'. If you don't like thatjust read the books or write your own stories and read them.

Your Name:
Reason for this Report:

  • The review is offensive.
  • The review is spam or chit-chat (not actually a review).
  • The review was double posted.
  • The review has formatting problems.
Repeat the number: 395
Submit Report: