Report a Review

This service is designed to allow HPFF users to alert the staff about inappropriate reviews.

Review:sapphire_skies says:
Itís an interesting beginning. It draws me in as a reader, thereís enough background to give me a good idea as to back up the charactersí state of mind and enough movement to keep me wanting to read more. However, I wasnít really a fan of the opening sentence. I feel itís a bit too bluntly stated and impersonal for a character that we know so well in the books. Iím not a fan in general of things like that, so perhaps it is me being a little subjective, but it put me off a little.

I do like the mood and the tone youíve set for the piece. I think itís probably fairly accurate for the aftermath of a war that had such an impact on a fairly small community and claimed a lot of lives. I think youíve done well with the emotion so far, it again is believable and the things Ron notices are very in character. I was particularly taken with the way he was affected more by the state of the shop than seeing his brotherís face, though I canít quite see why there would have been a picture of Fred and George above the shop, as there isnít one in canon. But it was very effective.

With regards to characterisation, there wasnít all that much in this chapter to go off, but what you did have was quite good.
The mentions of the Weasley family felt accurate, and I really liked the line, ĎThey were everything that they wanted to be, and Ron was always, deep down, jealous.í I think it shows the growth of Ronís character that he is able to admit that he was jealous of them, and I think itís something heíd only be able to do after heís been through the events of the last book.

On the technical side of things, there were a few awkward sentences, for example the second, ĎNo one who didnít have to be out and about was aroundí, and some that didnít entirely make sense (ĎNone of the Weasleys wanted to do anything, or, more accurately, didnít know what to do anymoreí), but spelling and punctuation was generally good.

A good start overall.

Author's Response: I'll be sure to rework that first sentence and the awkward ones on my next update of this, thank you for pointing them out :)

I'm glad you think I did well with the emotion. That was probably one of the hardest things to capture, as I have to real experience with war and its aftermath.

Thank you!

Your Name:
Reason for this Report:

  • The review is offensive.
  • The review is spam or chit-chat (not actually a review).
  • The review was double posted.
  • The review has formatting problems.
Repeat the number: 794
Submit Report: