Report a Review

This service is designed to allow HPFF users to alert the staff about inappropriate reviews.

Review:lilypotterfan123 says:
As much as I love this ship, I'm glad Minerva walked away and that she didn't give in. Partly because Minerva isn't like that so it would'e been OOC and the plot in itself seemed very canon. This story shows a more corrupt side of Tom and I think that we aught to remember that although when he's with Minerva they should be in love, there's a time when Tom becomes Voldemort and no one can want a monster. Unless you're just as corrupt as them, so unless you're Bellatrix Lestrange.

The way you write this ship is amazing but I've already told you this too many times so everything I say is getting old pretty much, soon I'll just send a record player with me saying the same old thing and compliments because I'll never ever get over your talent and I am lost for words each time I read your stories.

Ooh I've just had a thought. I know you like The Beatles and ABBA, a lot of your titles are based on ABBA especially so what if you did a poison kitty story that wasn't necessarily a song fic but based around one of their songs, like One of Us? If I had the talents I'd do it but I'm rubbish so you know, I doubt it would ever happen. Just think of it as a suggestion ;)

Thanks so much for writing this, as for a rating my maths teacher says there's no such thing as 110% so I doubt he's read you're work. This is 200% perfection. Hopefully that makes sense *yeah I don't think you can put perfection into percentages but ah well*.

Bex x

Author's Response: Thank you so much for your review! It's a wonderful treat to get a review for this story, which is probably the best I've ever done, or at least it's been regarded as such. There's something about it that just worked out, and I'm really glad that you enjoyed reading it.

Your compliments are super-inspiring, and they've gotten me thinking about writing more Tom/Minerva again. The Moody/McGonagall/Riddle story I'm working on isn't the same as just writing Tom and Minerva together - most of it has to do with the timing, that he can't of become Voldemort yet and she is still young enough to want to see the good in him. To move their relationship into their adulthood would be way too complicated - it's just like you said: she couldn't love a monster and he would only use her and torture her. It's a very time-sensitive ship.

ABBA is usually my inspiration for the next-generation stories, but there are songs like "One of Us", "Cassandra", or "Should I Laugh or Cry" that would fit Tom/Minerva, too. I will think about this - it's a very good suggestion, and it might be the push I need to get inspiration for writing a new Tom/Minerva. :D

Thank you so much for this! I can't thank you enough, Bex. It means a lot that you liked this story to such a degree. ^_^

Your Name:
Reason for this Report:

  • The review is offensive.
  • The review is spam or chit-chat (not actually a review).
  • The review was double posted.
  • The review has formatting problems.
Repeat the number: 368
Submit Report: