Report a Review

This service is designed to allow HPFF users to alert the staff about inappropriate reviews.

Review:PLEASE RESPOND/TAKE INTO CONSIDERATION says:
PLEASE RESPOND TO THIS RREVIEW!!!
Okay, Remus's speech is very sweet, but does Tonks realize what exactly he's saying? And also: The whole "just thinking about something can't make it happen" means that...if that were true, she would die (because she wanted to kill herself for a bit) or he would love her and always be with her (husband, lover, etc.) righht?! I'm just a bit confused but I think I get it now. Also, just to say my thoughts, I don't think you're portraying the characters right in the way of: Remus would NEVER leave Tonks and not talk to her and stuff, and Tonks would NEVER kill herself. She's a bright person, and I know she would be depressed if Remus left her, but she wouldn't commit suicide. She just wouldn't. And Remus wouldn't leave her like that. I just have to remind myself, "It's a fanfic, this didn't really happen!" And I hate Todd and every person Tonks has quote "dated" because I just want Remus + Tonks

Author's Response: I respond to all my reviews :) Yes, that's what I meant when talking about the power of thought :) I don't think Tonks would ever do that either, but that isn't to say the thought hasn't crossed her mind. And Remus didn't leave without talking to her, he did explain...sorta :P

Aww...you don't like Todd? Why not? (other than the fact that Tonks belongs with Remus). You are right, this is fanfic and just my interpretation of it :P And to be honest, this is a pretty old fic, I finished writing it last year, it's just taken me a while to put it up.

But thank you for the review. I liked reading your thoughts and impressions of the story :)
~Lily


Your Name:
Reason for this Report:

Examples:
  • The review is offensive.
  • The review is spam or chit-chat (not actually a review).
  • The review was double posted.
  • The review has formatting problems.
Repeat the number: 258
Submit Report: