Report a Review

This service is designed to allow HPFF users to alert the staff about inappropriate reviews.

Review:crazypotterweasley77 says:
So I just finished reading this whole fic today, and I loved it so much. I do ship ScoRose, but I just don't think it would work out if Rose and Scorpius ended up together. I don't particularly think that Lily and Scorpius belong with each other, either, but nor to Rose and Scorpius, and I have to say, I can sort of imagine Lily being a Mrs. Malfoy and all that. I also enjoyed the Teddy/Rose plot line. I was rather glad that it was Draco and not Scorpius at the door, too.

After the end of this story, a thought did occur to me: what would it be like if this story was told from a Lily-ish standpoint? Would Rose seem like the bad person and Lily the good? Hmm... I think it would make for an interesting idea...

Overall, this was a wonderful story and a delightful read and it just flowed so perfectly. You did a great job of developing each character and their personalities and so forth. I really loved this story, great job!

Author's Response: Thank you! It's wonderful to hear that you enjoyed the story - I know that it's unconventional in its shipping and its characterizations, but that makes it all the more a treat when readers like how things turned out in the end (especially you Scorose shippers :P).

You're right in that Scorpius and Lily aren't any better together than Scorpius and Rose was - personally, I can't see my Scorpius with anyone. Perhaps Rose had her chance in the past, and perhaps she could even have changed him, but now, he's become too twisted. Lily's in it for the position more than anything (which is silly because she is a Potter, and you'd think that would be enough). They definitely win the least compatible couple award. ;)

I'm VERY glad that you liked the Teddy/Rose plot - it was worrisome for me to try and pull off, since there was a faction of readers wanting to see Rose get together with Scorpius, or even go off on her own. I'm pleased that my own choice for things worked out for others. ^_^

Re: you comment on Lily's POV, I did write a one-shot from her perspective, "The Name of the Game", which looks at how she and Scorpius came to be a couple. It's rather disturbing, though, because it's told by Lily, but you might want to check it out. :)

Thank you again for the fantastic compliments! I can't thank you enough for loving this story. :D


Your Name:
Reason for this Report:

Examples:
  • The review is offensive.
  • The review is spam or chit-chat (not actually a review).
  • The review was double posted.
  • The review has formatting problems.
Repeat the number: 539
Submit Report: