Report a Review

This service is designed to allow HPFF users to alert the staff about inappropriate reviews.

Review:Alopex says:
I was really touched by what a big presence Cecilia had in this chapter. Naturally, her death is still fresh for her friends, so it stands to reason that they would still feel her loss as a big thing, a big hole in their group.

How typical that Molly overheard Arthur and Siobhan. Figures! I already knew Siobhan was going away (you said so in a review response, I think), but it was interesting to see the way she disclosed that information. Arthur really is a pretty safe guy to say that sort of thing to, and really, I was intrigued to see Arthur interacting with someone from the group other than his male pals and without Molly in the conversation. I can't remember if we've really seen that before or not.

Petula's question to Molly was hilarious. I had quite forgotten that she'd even asked in another story, but now I remember being amused by it when I read it.

This was a lovely end to the series. It did feel like a conclusion, although there's still room to fill in more should you ever wish to. I have so enjoyed following these characters over the last couple of years.

Author's Response: Yeah, Cecilia really left a gap in all their lives, and in their group. They are still dealing with it here, so her absence is felt pretty strongly.

Molly's nosy haha, she likes to know what's going on. Arthur's definitely a safe target, and she and Arthur have had a few run-ins on their own, or more often accompanied by Cecilia (since she and Siobhan were almost always together at school). I think I've shown only a few, but Arthur does mention that he's always liked Siobhan and she makes him laugh. Anyway, yes, Petula ;) It's almost her wedding here, so she's still thinking about that question.

I intended it to be a conclusion to this era, yeah, although then I went and wrote the one-shot collection. That's sort of a transition, though. Anyway, thank you so much, not just for this review but for all of them! You are one of my all-time favorite reviewers, of course, I always love reading what you said.

Your Name:
Reason for this Report:

  • The review is offensive.
  • The review is spam or chit-chat (not actually a review).
  • The review was double posted.
  • The review has formatting problems.
Repeat the number: 836
Submit Report: