Report a Review

This service is designed to allow HPFF users to alert the staff about inappropriate reviews.

Review:Margravine says:

first of all - VIVA LA (NOTT) REVOLUTION! It's so good to see more stories about him popping up, I'm a huge, huge Theodore Nott fangirl so I was all over this browsing the Story Seekers page even before I saw it was by you (bonus. Kaching!)

But the actual story - my crumbs (oh the words the 12+ rule puts in my mouth!) is it brilliant! The breaks are work well, it's choppy, but I think that fits the healing process. I ADORE the use of minor characters (most especially Slytherins) and your characters vivid and natural and AND THE ENDING TAKES IT TO A WHOLE OTHER LEVEL.

Sorry. Little bit worked up there. Was NOT expecting that. It does make the fic even better, but - but -but!

Anyway, loved, loved and will recommend to my Theodore Nott loving companions!

Author's Response: Margravine! ALOHA! (I do love your username.)

I shall start by proudly waving my flag and declaring 'OUI, VIVA LA NOTT REVOLUTION!' because Theodore Nott is one humdinger of a character and he deserves more stories than he's got. And Minor Slytherins kick some serious rear end. Ah, yes, if it wasn't for the 12+ rule, this review response would have a lot more in the way of capitals and naughty words.

I love your shouty praise! Ahh, this is the third attempt at an ending for this story. First ending: she played the chopin piece, it was all lovely and super-dooper and they lived happily forever after. I was all 'but that's what they expect!' and trashed it. Second ending: she didn't play the piece, but became a successful concert pianist and got over Theodore. I was all 'but no, she's supposed to be terrible at piano!' so now we have this one.

I am now tempted to form some sort of Nott society. Perhaps the TNAA (Theodore Nott Addicts Anonymous, although there'd be no reason for us to be anonymous because we would be vocal about our love for said Nott.)

Thanks, Danke and Merci for your lovely review!


Your Name:
Reason for this Report:

  • The review is offensive.
  • The review is spam or chit-chat (not actually a review).
  • The review was double posted.
  • The review has formatting problems.
Repeat the number: 192
Submit Report: