Report a Review

This service is designed to allow HPFF users to alert the staff about inappropriate reviews.

Review:marinahill says:
Gubby... I don't know what to say to you, in all honesty. You must know that you are one of my favourite authors of all time (both in fanfiction and in original fiction) because you've got one of the most beautiful styles I've ever come across. With every piece I read of yours I am more and more impressed. Your talent seems to know no bounds and for that I'll always keep coming back to read your work. One day, I'll sit down and read everything you've got to offer and I know I won't be disappointed. You never disappoint.

What is wonderful about every piece you craft is the beauty of your language. You must surely know how fabulous your style is, your description, your narrative, your voice... it's so unique and entrancing and I was easily sucked in right from the beginning. Every word is poetry and you don't even have to try (or so it would seem). I think what is most extraordinary is that not only are you an impressively talented writer, but your ideas are just absolutely stunning. I'd love to spend a day inside your mind and question your imagination because it surely has to be the most vivid and fascinating than anything I've seen portrayed on page before. if that makes any sense... and also doesn't come off as stalkerish. Because you honestly fascinate me because it seems like you could have been writing for years and years and years; every time I read something of yours I think you've surely reached perfection but then you go and improve and impress me once again. I've never seen anything like it.

Now, your ideas... I'll be very honest and admit that they're far beyond anything my poor little brain can cope with, but for me that's part of the enjoyment I get from reading your fics. I know that what I'm reading is superior to 99% of all fanfic because it's so advanced, so well-developed and so brilliantly formed. I finished this fic with my thinking cap on and I adore the stimulus. I'm not just blown away by your stunning writing but by the plots you manage to portray in so few words.

Another thing I loved was how we never find out who the characters are. Well, actually, I sometimes find that really annoying, just because I like to know who these people are so I can sort out the scene in my head. But that's just me, I wouldn't have this any other way. That mystery really enhances everything you've written about, from the description to the haunting dialogue dispersed between it. See, things like that would annoy me no end if not written well, but because your language and writing is so... I've exhausted all the adjectives, but because you're so good at what you do you stop me from caring about technicalities. I was utterly sucked in.

I absolutely adored this line (as well as many others): the gesture sweeps over the vast ruination of the world, the dirty skies and the tawdry houses, the graying countryside and the corrupt cities. Just absolutely, simply beautiful.

Thanks for requesting, I'm sorry I can't give any coherent/constructive feedback. You've blown me away.

- Marina

Your Name:
Reason for this Report:

  • The review is offensive.
  • The review is spam or chit-chat (not actually a review).
  • The review was double posted.
  • The review has formatting problems.
Repeat the number: 535
Submit Report: