Report a Review

This service is designed to allow HPFF users to alert the staff about inappropriate reviews.

Review:miss_ravenclaw09 says:
AWW! :( That was so sad! But so amazing at the same time!

Man, the part with Harry in the Room of Requirement totally got me. I love it. Both of the song-fics connect together so well! And you can totally feel Hermione's grief, and I personally wanted to cry with her. I'm a sucker for emotion in stories. That's usually what gets me into a story, and you have that down-pat. Great job! :)

I also love how you describe Harry's heaven. Quidditch all day with his dad, hanging out with Sirius, and getting to see his mom is probably what his heaven would be like. And the window thing is brilliant. I always wondered if there was actual ground on heaven or if you floated on clouds or something (I would be scared I would fall through). The window kind of gives me a solid ground I can invision Harry on in my mind.

I like it! Your song-fics are awesome! You really know how to capture the emotionality of a song, and you do an awesome job with it. :D


Author's Response: :D You know, I'm not really sure where the Room of Requirement thing came from.. it just sort of hit me that if the room gives you what you need, and what you need is closure, it would provide it.
Isn't Harry's heaven wonderful? I want to go there. lol. I think my brain was going along the lines of The Elysian Fields with that one.. then again, I'm really into Mythologoy so it's no big surprise there.. lol.
So glad you enjoyed this story.. Only a few more oneshots to go then I get to start sending you my longer stories :)

Thanks for another wonderful review!

Your Name:
Reason for this Report:

  • The review is offensive.
  • The review is spam or chit-chat (not actually a review).
  • The review was double posted.
  • The review has formatting problems.
Repeat the number: 172
Submit Report: